Judge took trips with lawyer in two cases

Feb. 27, 2004 at 9:51 AM
share with facebook
share with twitter

WASHINGTON, Feb. 27 (UPI) -- U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia says there were no ethical breaches when he went on hunting trips organized by a lawyer with cases pending before him.

The Los Angeles Times said Friday Scalia was the guest of a Kansas law school two years ago and went pheasant hunting on a trip arranged by the school's law school dean, Stephen McAllister, all within weeks of hearing two cases in which the dean was a lead attorney.

The cases involved issues of public policy important to Kansas officials, namely disputed laws to confine sex offenders and a prison program for treating sex offenders.

Scalia eventually sided with Kansas in both cases.

In a written statement, Scalia said: "I do not think that spending time at a law school in which the counsel in pending cases was the dean could reasonably cause my impartiality to be questioned."

Not all legal professionals agree.

"When a case is on the docket before a judge, the coziness of meeting privately with a lawyer is questionable," said Chicago lawyer Robert Cummins, who headed an Illinois board on judicial ethics. "It would seem the better part of judgment to avoid those situations."

Related UPI Stories
Trending Stories