Tuesday night's episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live featured a seemingly unknowing Krasinski being told that Kimmel shared his personal home address all over the greater Los Angeles area for a fake yard sale.
Although maintaining his cool, Krasinski was visibly shocked by Kimmel's prank. "Do you ever forget to laugh because all you're thinking about is, 'This is gonna be so awful'?" the 13 Hours actor said before getting an extra surprise-- a dousing of creamy eggnog.
As his own form of payback, a soaked Krasinski jumped over the sofa separating the two and embraced Kimmel, effectively soaking the host as well.