Fight over San Diego cross back in court

Published: April 16, 2008 at 12:39 AM
Order reprints
SAN DIEGO, April 16 (UPI) -- The two-decade-old dispute over a 43-foot cross on public land in San Diego returned to court this week.

The land at the summit of Mount Soledad originally belonged to the city but was transferred to the Defense Department in 2006. Now the Jewish War Veterans and a San Diego resident, Steve Trunk, are challenging the transfer, the San Diego Union-Tribune reported.

Supporters of the cross say it is part of a memorial to veterans. Opponents say it is an unconstitutional religious symbol.

A federal judge first ordered the cross to be removed in 1991. The original suit was brought by Philip Paulson, an atheist and Vietnam Veteran who has since died.

U.S. District Judge Larry Burns, during Monday's hearing, hinted he might rule for the federal government, saying that courts have to give deference to Congress and that the bill authorizing the transfer referred to a "memorial." He also said he expects years of appeals however he rules.

"I don't have any illusions I'm going to be the last word on this," Burns said.


© 2008 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.



Canadian PM apologizes at G8 for blunder (48 min)
Cruz added to AL All-Star team
Couple in Lisa Nowak case set to marry
UPI NewsTrack Health and Science News
UPI NewsTrack Quirks in the News
ROTC cadet dies during training exercise
Lead level prompts recall of Sport Balls
fark
It's been 10 years since "The Blair Witch Project." Where were you when this crappy, one-joke, overhyped...
While serious people debate health care, CNN does interview with morons from West Virgina who ignored...
Swim club president clarifies racial misunderstanding. The issue is safety, not race; "Many of them...
CNN delves into the hard-hitting story others are too timid to confront: What do psychics have to...
Prospect Heights, Illinois Police Department HQ to close to the public on Fridays. Citizens are...
This sounds safe: 500,000 people with access to military weapons, all going through nicotine withdrawal...