Senators goalie Craig Anderson was injured during a scoreless overtime when Dallas' Valeri Nichuskin fell on top of him, delivering a thigh to his head. Anderson was taken off the ice on a stretcher and was replaced by Robin Lehner.
The contest moved to a shootout, where Benn beat Lehner with a shot to the glove side in the second round.
Kari Lehtonen then made a sliding stop on Ryan, and the Stars began a three-game road trip with a victory.
Nichuskin and Ray Whitney scored and Lehtonen finished with 33 saves for Dallas.
Ryan, Eric Karlsson and Jason Spezza each provided a goal an assist for the Senators, who fell in a shootout for a second straight game.
Anderson stopped 33-of-36 shot before leaving with his injury and Lehner turned aside both shots he faced in overtime.
Beautician charged with giving client fatal silicone butt injection
McPhee, Cokas 'working on their marriage' after affair