As Letterman revisited the past, he also decided to talk about the last time Bieber was on the show and how the conversation got so intense the pop-idol broke down.
"The last time he was on, he and I got into a conversation," Letterman began. "And I made him cry."
"Well, then that makes two of us," Gomez said to a cheering audience.
The two then fist bumped and cracked up laughing. I guess that settles it, Letterman is on Team Selena.
Aaron Carter is still in love with Hilary Duff
NBC reportedly holds celebs hostage to Jimmy Fallon's show