Advertisement

Commentary: Silver linings in war clouds

By ARNAUD DE BORCHGRAVE, Editor at Large

WASHINGTON, March 8 (UPI) -- Word from Saudi insiders who were privy to recent talks in Riyadh between King Abdullah and Iran's Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is encouraging, but it will almost surely disappoint those who favor bombing Iran's nuclear installations. Speaking off the record, one Saudi topsider confided the Iranian president had flown back across the Gulf "a much chastened and worried man."

The seven hours Ahmadinejad spent with Abdullah on his first visit to the kingdom were cut in half by time needed for translation, as they don't speak each other's languages (Farsi and Arabic). But the talks had been well-prepared by national security advisers from both countries. Iran's Ali Larijani and Prince Bandar bin Sultan shuttled back and forth between Tehran and Riyadh.

Advertisement

Ahmadinejad even pledged "to cool things down in both Iraq and Lebanon," two countries where Iran has more influence than any other power or combination of powers -- in Lebanon through Hezbollah and in Iraq through a Shiite-led coalition government and Shiite militias armed, trained and funded by Tehran's Revolutionary Guards.

Advertisement

Ahmadinejad remained adamant on the nuclear issue -- no turning back from uranium enrichment -- but then, unlike President George W. Bush, he is not the chief "decider" in Tehran. Assuming the Saudis read Ahmadinejad's "chastened mood" accurately, it then remains to be seen how much influence the diminutive hothead can exercise over the key instruments of Iranian power he does not control.

Anything that matters in Iran is the purview of Supreme Guide Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and the 86-man Council of Guardians, chaired by Ahmadinejad's arch rival Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani, himself president for eight years following the 1980-88 war with Iraq. He has been openly critical of Ahmadinejad's travels abroad where he threatened death and damnation on the remaining "evil empire," the United States, and its "devil incarnate," Mr. Bush.

There is a growing chorus of public and private protest in Tehran against Ahmadinejad's extremist sound bites that only serve to further isolate Iran abroad. His wild utterances sparked anti-Shiite sentiments throughout the Middle East and mobilized Arab opinion against Iran.

King Abdullah apparently convinced Ahmadinejad that a U.S. bombing campaign on Iran would not be limited to the nuclear sites that are dug deep underground. The Iranian was made to understand if Bush opts for an air campaign, Iran would become the target for hundreds of bombing sorties against key installations across the length and breadth of Iran. Not only would Iran be set back several years, but the entire region would most probably explode against all the countries that have sided with the United States.

Advertisement

While such a scenario might appeal to Ahmadinejad's vision of the Apocalypse Now, which his own Shiite strain anticipates will be the prelude to the return of the 12th Imam, or Mahdi, who will then lead a dominant Islam to a new age of peace and plenty, his clerical superiors do not look forward to being bombed back to the Stone Age. Nor does any rational Muslim look forward with equanimity to a regional religious war of Shiite Islam vs. Sunni Islam, in effect a war between Iran and the Arab world.

The compromise now being bruited among European diplomats who work the Iranian file would allow Iran to move to the tipping point of a nuclear weapons manufacturing capability -- but then refrain, under U.N. verification, from actually producing them.

In return, sanctions would be lifted, and the U.S. would agree to restore diplomatic relations with Iran, lift all sanctions and pledge non-aggression. This would be a page from the Libyan playbook when Col. Moammar Gadhafi agreed to turn over all the nuclear bomb-making equipment purchased from Pakistan's Dr. A. Q. Khan in return for normalization with the United States and Britain. But from here to there is still a long, arduous diplomatic journey strewn with booby traps and war drums calling for "bombs away" over Iran.

Advertisement

The Bush administration -- through the voices of Condoleezza Rice and Robert Gates -- has made clear the U.S. is not looking for a pretext for war with Iran, "nor do we desire war with Iran." But U.S. military clout is all around Iran, by air, land and sea, should Iranian entities that are not controlled by Ahmadinejad -- such as the Revolutionary Guards, Quds commandos, and intelligence assets -- push their luck in aiding anti-American insurgents in Iraq.

Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid says the president does not have the authority to launch attacks against Iran without first seeking approval from Congress. The White House, on the other hand, believes it can invoke the right to self-defense under Article 51 of the U.N. Charter if Iran doesn't cease and desist clandestine assistance to the insurgency.

The Saudi monarch made clear the kingdom would not stand idly by if Iran continued to harass and thus impede a U.S. withdrawal from Iraq. Unknown amounts of secret Saudi financial assistance have already gone to Sunni insurgents. Covert U.S. and Israeli aid has also found its way to anti-regime militants in Iran.

Diplomacy moved center stage in Baghdad March 10 for a regional security conference with a plethora of players, ranging from Iraq's seven neighbors to the Arab League, the U.N., Russia, the U.S. and European Union. China, with a large stake in steady, uninterrupted oil supplies, also wants a seat in any forum concerned with Middle Eastern security. The prospect of a gigantic upheaval in the Middle East, triggered by a combination of Iran pushing its luck in Iraq and Lebanon, and the U.S. retaliating militarily, put Saudi diplomacy to the test. So far, it's a Saudi success story.

Advertisement

Iran's leaders won't soon forget Saudi financial clout. During the Iran-Iraq war, Saudi Arabia mobilized tens of billions of dollars from all the Arab Gulf countries -- to assist Saddam Hussein. This time, King Abdullah has decided his kingdom will not tolerate an Iranian nuclear weapons capability, a few miles away across the Gulf. Neither will the Bush administration. Nor will Israel.

Latest Headlines