Hogan told police that surveillance footage at his Clearwater Beach, Fla., shop, Hogan's Beach Shop, showed three women distracting the manager while a fourth took off with the boot signed by Hogan.
Employees at the shop didn't noticed the piece of memorabilia was missing until viewing the security tapes a couple days after the incident.
Hogan said he plans to file a police report, but so far there were no charges against the woman, who is now back in Michican.
She arranged to have the boot returned to the shop and admitted it was "a stupid thing" to do.
Celebrity Families of 2014 [PHOTOS]