Sections
Log in
Top News
U.S. News World News Featured Voices
Odd News
Entertainment
Movies Music TV
Sports
Soccer NFL NBA MLB
Photos
News Entertainment Sports Features
More...
Defense Featured Science Health Video Archive Almanac
About Feedback Privacy Policy
About Feedback Privacy Policy
Search
Trending
Vaping
Cowboy pigeons
Impeachment
New Jersey shooting
Dallas Stars
Nemanja Bjelica
Derrick Rose
New Zealand volcano
Megan Rapinoe
Boston slaying
U.S. News
Oct. 4, 2019 / 3:00 AM

Farmers get 'negligible' benefit from insecticide that may kill bees, researchers say

By
Jessie Higgins
Soybeans treated with a controversial insecticide called neonicitenoids have a minimal yield improvement, a new study found. File Photo by Mike Theiler/UPI | License Photo

EVANSVILLE, Ind., Oct. 4 (UPI) -- New research has found a widely used and increasingly controversial class of insecticide has "negligible" benefits for commercially grown soybeans. Pesticide makers and farmers disagree.

The class of insecticide, called neonicotinoid, has come under fire in recent years after scientists discovered it might be killing honey bees, monarch butterflies, certain birds and aquatic life.

"We've documented the costs and the downsides of neonicotinoids," said Christian Krupke, an entomology professor at Purdue University, who was one of the 23 researchers who authored a study on the topic.

"So the question we asked with this study was, what are the benefits? Do these insecticides pay off for growers? Do they prevent pest damage? And our findings are that the benefits are negligible."

RELATED Scientists scramble to learn why monarch butterflies are dying so quickly

The study was an analysis of nearly 200 field studies that evaluated the effects of neonicotinoids on soybean yields across the United States.

The compiled results showed that, on average, neonicotinoid-treated crops produced an average of 2 additional bushels per acre than non-treated crops. When compared to the added cost farmers paid for the insecticide, the payoff is slim, the study concluded.

Contrary opinion

RELATED U.S. farm bankruptcies rise as trade war drags on

The companies that produce the insecticide and the farmers who use it were quick to refute that verdict.

"The entomologists and agronomists who published this paper might not think that a 2 bushel-per-acre yield increase is a big deal, but clearly growers do," Bayer Crop Science, which sells neonicotinoid-treated soybean seeds, said in an emailed statement.

"And we do, too. The benefits of neonicotinoid seed treatments are well established, which is why thousands of farmers choose to use them every season -- based, like all crop-protection products, on the needs and challenges of their individual fields."

RELATED China's decision to cease agricultural imports rocks U.S. farmers

These are farmers like Wayne Fredricks, who grows corn and soybeans in northern Iowa.

"I read through the study," Fredricks said. "It points out that there are certain areas where neonic use is more responsive than others, and we fall right in the middle of one of those areas."

Fredericks -- who employs multiple conservation farming methods, including planting cover crops and not tilling his soil to reduce fertilizer runoff, tested the effect of neonicotinoids on his farm in 2015. He found that the insecticide increased his yields that year by an average of 0.8 bushel per acre.

That 0.8 bushel is an additional $7.20 per acre, if the beans sell at $9 per bushel. (Their price Thursday was $9.11.) The insecticide costs roughly $4 per acre, he said. With 300 acres of soybeans, that means Fredericks earns roughly an additional $1,000 from his harvest by using the insecticide.

"That's an 80 percent return on investment in six months," he said.

Pests a problem

What's more, Fredericks farms in an area that is prone to the kind of seed-eating pests neonicotinoids target, he said. He has lost crops to those pests before.

"We had a case where part of our soybean crop was totally devoured by seed corn maggots and we had to totally replant," he said. "So I know the damage pests can do. That's always in the back of my mind. I know what can happen."

Aside from boosting yield, neonicotinoids are popular among farmers because they provide insurance against such widespread crop loss.

That popularity is broad. Neonicotinoids are the most widely used insecticide in the world, said Scott McArt, an entomology professor at Cornell University, who was not involved in the soybean study.

In the United States, some 40 percent of commercially grown soybeans are treated with neonicotinoids, according to the study. Corn is closer to 100 percent, McArt said.

The substance is a chemically altered version of nicotine.

"The name literally means 'new nicotine,'" McArt said. "The reason nicotine is there in plants is to protect them against insects. The [neonicotinoid] molecule has been synthesized to have a more potent effect on insects. We've altered the compound to be more toxic."

The insecticide first appeared on the market in the mid-1990s and its use grew quickly.

Less toxic

Neonicotinoids are less toxic to vertebrates, like humans, than other kinds of insecticides that were used at the time. Unlike those other insecticides, which had to be sprayed directly onto plant leaves, neonicotinoids are absorbed into the plant through the seeds.

As the plant grows, the substance becomes part of its tissue. That means farmers can buy neonicotinoid-coated seeds instead of spraying their fields with other chemicals.

But the new data on the insecticide's effect on wildlife has many questioning its use.

Multiple studies have shown that neonicotinoids leach off those treated seeds and into the surrounding environment. Once there, they are absorbed into the tissue of wild plants. This makes them a great risk to honey bees, monarch butterflies and other pollinators, according to Cornell University's Pollinator Network.

Other studies have shown the insecticide harms invertebrate aquatic animals and certain types of birds.

The European Union recently banned neonicotinoid use, Canada is considering more restrictions and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is conducting a neonicotinoid review that it will release for public comment at the end of this year.

Pesticide producers and scientists warn that placing restrictions on neonicotinoids could result in an increase in the use of other -- more dangerous -- insecticides.

"The assumption that we're going to stop using neonicotinoids and they're not going to be replaced is unrealistic," McArt said. "They will be replaced with other chemical compounds, and those chemical compounds might pose even greater risks. That's something that's not talked about all that much."

Alternates not better

Bayer made a similar point.

"The loss of neonicotinoids would force growers to rely on few older classes of insecticides," the company said.

This argument was one of the key reasons for conducting the meta-analysis of soybean yields, said Krupke, one of the study's authors. Based on the findings, he believes most farmers don't need to be using this kind of insecticide.

"They're sold under the banner that you never know what pests are going to show up, so you'd better treat crops to be on the safe side," Krupke said. "What we showed is the pests just aren't usually there. If they were there, we would be able to see them in untreated seeds. We would have seen them because they would have gobbled them up."

Lacking government intervention, it's up to individual farmers whether they buy neonicotinoid-treated seeds or not.

"If they're in an area that doesn't show an economic response, it may make sense for farmers to not use it," Iowa's Fredericks said.

He added that seed companies are experimenting with ways to reduce chemical leaching by applying it to the seeds with stickier substances.

"I don't disregard the environmental concerns," said Fredericks, who is a member of the National Monarch Collaborative, and sets aside multiple acres of his property for pollinator habitat.

"There is room all around to make improvements. But it should be left up to the individual farmers to make that decision based on what they see in the results from their area."

  • Topics
  • Business
  • U.S. Farming

Latest Headlines

Pete Buttigieg reveals list of McKinsey clients
U.S. News // 46 minutes ago
Pete Buttigieg reveals list of McKinsey clients
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg on Tuesday released a list of clients that he advised for while employed by elite management consulting firm McKinsey & Company.

U.S. suspends operational training of Saudi students at military bases
U.S. News // 1 hour ago
U.S. suspends operational training of Saudi students at military bases
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- The United States suspended operational training of Saudi students at military locations and called for revisions to its vetting process for international military students on Tuesday.

Federal judge blocks plan to divert $3.6B in military funding for border wall
U.S. News // 2 hours ago
Federal judge blocks plan to divert $3.6B in military funding for border wall
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- A federal judge blocked $3.6 billion in military funding the Trump administration planned to divert to pay for construction of a border wall.

Trump, Democrats agree to U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade deal
U.S. News // 11 hours ago
Trump, Democrats agree to U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade deal
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- House Democrats and the Trump administration have reached an agreement on the United States-Mexico-Canada trade deal to replace the North American Free Trade Agreement, both sides announced Tuesday.

Merriam-Webster announces 'they' as 2019 Word of the Year
U.S. News // 4 hours ago
Merriam-Webster announces 'they' as 2019 Word of the Year
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- "They" was Merriam-Webster's Word of the Year of the Year for 2019, reflecting its use as a pronoun for non-binary people.

Active shooting in New Jersey leaves 6 dead, including officer
U.S. News // 7 hours ago
Active shooting in New Jersey leaves 6 dead, including officer
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- A gun battle at a Jersey City, N.J., bodega Tuesday left six people dead, including a police officer and two suspects, local authorities said.

Boston man convicted for killing two doctors
U.S. News // 5 hours ago
Boston man convicted for killing two doctors
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- A Boston jury on Tuesday found a man guilty of two counts of first-degree murder for killing two doctors in their home in 2017.

U.S. court unveils charges against Genaro Garcia Luna tied to El Chapo's cartel
U.S. News // 5 hours ago
U.S. court unveils charges against Genaro Garcia Luna tied to El Chapo's cartel
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- Mexico's former secretary of public security, Genaro Garcia Luna, faces federal charges in New York for allegedly taking millions in bribes to protect the drug cartel once run by Joaquin "El Chapo" Guzman

Lisa Page sues Trump administration for releasing text messages
U.S. News // 6 hours ago
Lisa Page sues Trump administration for releasing text messages
Dec. 10 (UPI) -- Former FBI lawyer Lisa Page sued the Trump administration Tuesday for releasing hundreds of text messages between herself and a former FBI agent with whom she had a romantic relationship.

NASA gears up to test fire new SLS moon rocket in Mississippi
U.S. News // 6 hours ago
NASA gears up to test fire new SLS moon rocket in Mississippi
STENNIS SPACE CENTER, Miss.,Dec. 10 (UPI) -- NASA is getting ready to test fire the largest rocket since the Apollo era at the sprawling Stennis Space Center in southern Mississippi, where the new SLS moon rocket's first stage is expected to arrive in early 2020.

Trending Stories

Impeachment: House charges Trump with abuse of power, obstruction
Impeachment: House charges Trump with abuse of power, obstruction
New Zealand volcano: Criminal probe launched; death toll rises to six
New Zealand volcano: Criminal probe launched; death toll rises to six
Active shooting in New Jersey leaves 6 dead, including officer
Active shooting in New Jersey leaves 6 dead, including officer
Efficiency, new seismic standards behind $2B high-tech California hospital
Efficiency, new seismic standards behind $2B high-tech California hospital
NASA unveils core stage of new Artemis moon rocket
NASA unveils core stage of new Artemis moon rocket

Photo Gallery

 
Hemingway watches, 'Dupont Emerald' on display at Christie's preview
Hemingway watches, 'Dupont Emerald' on display at Christie's preview

Latest News

Philadelphia Phillies to sign former New York Yankees SS Didi Gregorius
Missouri introduces Appalachian State's Eli Drinkwitz as 33rd head football coach
Pete Buttigieg reveals list of McKinsey clients
Patriots' Bill Belichick on Bengals sideline video: 'I have no involvement in this'
U.S. suspends operational training of Saudi students at military bases
 
Back to Article
/
Back to top
About UPI Contact Feedback Advertisements Submit News Tips
Copyright © 2019 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy