Fredrik Modin had the lone even-strength goal for Tampa Bay midway through the third period -- his 22nd career goal against the Rangers.
Bobby Holik, Eric Lindros and defenseman Joel Bouchard scored for New York. Goaltender Mike Dunham was peppered with 43 shots, including 34 over the opening 40 minutes.
Holik had four penalties called against him, including three in the final period. Teammate Dave Karpa also cost the Rangers with three penalties.
Jessica Simpson shares three-way kiss with friends in photo
Interpol investigating stolen passports on missing flight