Advertisement

China is a threat, but has some unmistakable weaknesses

By
Harlan Ullman, Arnaud de Borchgrave Distinguished Columnist
A Chinese delegate leaves the fourth session of the 13th National People's Congress held in the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on Monday. Photo by Stephen Shaver/UPI | License Photo

Conventional wisdom, shared by members of Congress in both parties and the interim National Security Strategy released last week, considers China "the pacing threat" and America's strongest competitor.

The reasons at first examination look compelling. China's economy may overtake America's. China may be ahead in game-changing technologies such as artificial intelligence, 5G and other areas.

Advertisement

China has fielded a modern military with a navy of about 500 ships (with many patrol boats and small craft, while substantially larger than the U.S. Navy's 300 ship fleet, is not nearly as capable). China has become more aggressive in the region in pursuing its aims. Questions arise about the future integrity of Taiwan as an independent state.

And "Belt and Road" is a multitrillion-renminbi program to gain access and influence through off-shore investments and loans. Taken together, these factors argue that China is out to challenge the United States as a global leader in virtually every category.

RELATED U.S., Japan security meeting to address deterrence against China, report says

However, is this a complete assessment of China? The answer is no because it lacks a balanced analysis and evaluation of both strengths and weaknesses. Consider this historical comparison.

In October, China celebrates the 72nd anniversary of the founding of the People's Republic in 1949. In October 1989, the Soviet Union celebrated its 72nd anniversary. Less than two months later, the Berlin War came down, beginning the dissolution of the Soviet Union.

Advertisement

No one is suggesting that China is close to collapse. But hidden among the more obvious examples of China's growing power and influence are otherwise unmistakable weaknesses and issues. Unless these are understood, as the collapse of the Soviet Union came as a welcome surprise, China, too, may be subject to huge domestic pressures and an increasingly controlling party structure that risks alienating substantial segments of the population.

RELATED Report: China's treatment of Uighurs breaches U.N. genocide convention

The Chinese Communist Party under the Xi Jingping administration appears to have abandoned Deng Xiao Peng's policy of rule by consensus, and a large degree of economic freedom is crucial to creating a modern and advanced society. Crackdowns on hyper-rich Chinese businessmen; strict adherence to Marxist-Leninist ideology; crushing dissent whether in Xinjiang, Hong Kong or internally; and the purging of political rivals are not signs of a healthy political system, especially when innovation is dependent upon entrepreneurship that cannot be dictated by Marx or Lenin.

Belt and Road has deprived hundreds of millions of China's nearly 1.5 billion citizens of needed funds to improve local standards of living. Over 100,000 large-scale protests a year have been reported as Chinese calls for more resources at home and ending rampant corruption that favors a few rather than the many. A combination of so-called social credits that grade Chinese people on loyalty and credit worthiness and facial recognition enable the CCP to exert further controls on Chinese society.

Advertisement

The internal financial system with huge debt; a shadow banking organization; a possible real-estate bubble; and the need for significant real annual economic growth to respond to the expectations for better standards of living raise massive challenges for the leadership in Beijing.

RELATED Report: Chinese military bases near Taiwan show new renovations

The "one-child" policy has led to an "aging" population in which the ratio of retirees to workers is headed in the wrong direction. And men outnumber women by about 20%, meaning many men will not find spouses.

China also lacks viable allies. Still, China has managed to contain the United States by signing free-trade agreements with the United Kingdom and the European Union and the 15 state Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnerships strengthening its potential for economic growth.

Perhaps the possible political cancers that could infect China are first the increasing autocratic control of the CCP over the public, which stifles economic productivity, and second, a debt-ridden balance sheet that could lead to a financial crisis. The Soviets suffered from the first. And then Secretary-General Mikhail Gorbachev tried to reform what was a failed system igniting the implosion. The more China attempts to control its population, the more it risks a backlash.

Chinese leaders understand that for centuries, peasant and other revolutions wracked the country. The most recent was the lengthy civil war ending in 1949. A future revolution may take another form. But make no mistake. China is not an unstoppable colossus. The fact is that, as in the former Soviet Union, China has an oppressive political-ideological regime that limits human ingenuity, imagination and innovation. This may prove to be the fatal flaw in Chinese aspirations.

Advertisement

In the 1980s, Japan's boom led to the wrong premise that Japan would dominate world economies. That did not happen. Will the same outcome apply to China?

Harlan Ullman is UPI's Arnaud deBorchgrave Distinguished Columnist and author of the upcoming book "The Fifth Horseman and the New MAD: The Tragic History of How Massive Attacks of Disruption Endangered, Infected, Engulfed and Disunited a 51% Nation and the Rest of the World."

Latest Headlines