Sections
Log in
Top News
U.S. News World News Featured Voices
Odd News
Entertainment
Movies Music TV
Sports
Soccer NFL NBA MLB
Photos
News Entertainment Sports Features
More...
Defense Featured Science Health Video Archive Almanac
About Feedback Privacy Policy
About Feedback Privacy Policy
Search
Breaking News
Labor Dept. says U.S. economy added 266,000 jobs in November, far exceeding expectations
Trending
Taylor Swift
Measles
North Korea
Kennedy Space Center
Prison workers
Angela Merkel
UPS hostage
Helicopter crash
Tennessee execution
Michael Bloomberg
Voices
Dec. 28, 2018 / 8:12 AM

Breaches could spur users to opt out of sharing personal data

By
Douglas Yeung
Facebook opened a one-day popup kiosk on December 13 at Bryant Park in New York City to field questions about its data-sharing practices. Photo by John Angelillo/UPI | License Photo

Dec. 28 (UPI) -- The New York Times reported recently that Facebook gave tech giants like Amazon and Microsoft greater access to users' personal data than it had previously acknowledged, and although Facebook issued a denial the episode could again send shivers down the spines of nervous privacy-conscious social media users.

As tech-based systems have become all but indispensable, many institutions might assume user data will be reliable, meaningful and, most of all, plentiful. But what if this data became unreliable, meaningless or even scarce? Seemingly lost in the debates over data ownership and privacy is the possibility that data availability could dwindle, rather than continuing to grow -- and change the booming business of data aggregation as we know it.

Most of the estimated 500 million people whose sensitive personal information was stolen in the Marriott data breach revealed last month had no say in how the information had been stored and protected, or how widely it might have been shared with other companies. Repeated data breaches have led Americans to be increasingly pessimistic that the personal data they give government and commercial entities is secure, a development that could cause people to stop sharing their data or to share it more judiciously. Public outrage over data breaches and distrust of government and tech companies also could diminish tech workers' appetite to develop technological innovations and corresponding systems that are built from and rely on large amounts of data.

If the public broadly opts out of using tech tools, or makes fewer efforts to build them, insufficient or unreliable user data could destabilize the data aggregation business model that powers much of the tech industry. Developers of technologies such as artificial intelligence, as well as businesses built on big data, could no longer count on ever-expanding streams of data. Without this data, machine learning models would be less accurate, and targeted ads would be less precise and thus less lucrative.

RELATED Washington, D.C., AG sues Facebook over Cambridge Analytica scandal

Institutions that enjoy access to this data (such as Facebook's trove of personal data) and the capacity to organize it (China's vast data-tagging workforce) could see these built-in advantages, which help them collect and make use of online data, begin to erode. It might, however, give rise to competitors with new business practices or methods of capturing user information, such as relying on data from voice assistants or smart connected devices.

Most Internet users seem to understand they are creating massive amounts of easily accessible data, either deliberately or inadvertently through "digital exhaust" -- the valuable personal data organizations capture and analyze for their own purposes, whether those are profit-driven, to support policy making, or for national security. Internet giants like Facebook and Google are built to leverage seemingly ceaseless flows of user-generated data, culled from web browsing or smartphone apps. Governments are exploring how to use social media or ride-sharing data to inform policy and decision making.

But the proliferation of hacking incidents appears to have altered the public conversation around online privacy, as well as online behavior. More than 50 percent of victims of a data breach surveyed for a RAND study had taken steps to maintain online privacy, such as changing passwords.

RELATED Google CEO doesn't rule out censored search engine in China

Tech users and developers appear increasingly willing to take principled stances against what they view as unethical or objectionable business practices. Populist attitudes that convey suspicion of the institutions that hold and exploit this data -- whether the organizations are based in Silicon Valley or Washington, D.C. -- could encourage people to curb their tech usage. For instance, an estimated 200,000 Uber users deleted their accounts with the ride-hailing service in early 2017 to protest perceived misbehavior by the company and the CEO. And Silicon Valley employees have staged walkouts and in some cases resigned to protest the actions of their employers.

Certain groups could end up opting out, skewing user data to make it unrepresentative of the broader population. Technologies and systems that are based on biased data can exacerbate inequities. The potential trend could be made worse if large numbers of minorities or entire communities declined to use tools and provide data to train algorithms.

Policymakers might want to consider exploring how to go about restoring trust in public and private institutions that collect personal data, which could include promoting transparency and accountability, or strengthening data security.

RELATED Marriott: Data breach may affect 500M hotel guests

Institutions built on the assumption of an unending flow of data should consider how to prepare for tech users to shut off the spigot. Approaches that account for these behavior shifts could include, for instance, artificial intelligence methods that do not rely on large amounts of training data, such as creating synthetic data rather than looking for real-world data.

Ensuring the long-term sustainability of data-based technologies will require that the data they rely on is accessible and representative of the population. That won't be possible if those who desire to acquire more of that data keep giving people reasons to opt out.

Douglas Yeung is a behavioral scientist at the nonprofit, nonpartisan RAND Corp. and serves on the faculty of the Pardee RAND Graduate School.

  • Topics
  • Google
  • Amazon

Latest Headlines

Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan key to U.S. interests in Central Asia
Voices // 1 hour ago
Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan key to U.S. interests in Central Asia
Dec. 6 (UPI) -- A geostrategic opportunity is opening for America in how Washington can advance the U.S. interests in a quickly shifting landscape in Central Asia. Two countries, Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, will play a key role.

Young protesters in Iran, Iraq will not be cowed
Voices // 1 day ago
Young protesters in Iran, Iraq will not be cowed
Dec. 5 (UPI) -- More than 1,000, mostly young, protesters have been murdered by Iran's theocratic fascist regime in the past two weeks, with more than 4,000 injured and 12,000 arrested.

NATO must recognize Russia as political, economic threat
Voices // 2 days ago
NATO must recognize Russia as political, economic threat
LONDON, Dec. 4 (UPI) -- This week, NATO heads of state and government gather at the Grove Hotel, the former estate of the dukes of Clarendon outside London, for a summit marking the alliance's 70th anniversary.

Growing Christian movement agrees with Rick Perry that God chose Donald Trump
Voices // 3 days ago
Growing Christian movement agrees with Rick Perry that God chose Donald Trump
Dec. 3 (UPI) -- A large number of evangelical Christians in the United States believe that God has chosen Donald Trump to advance the kingdom of God on Earth. Several high-profile religious leaders have made similar claims.

Iran uprising recalls bloody parallels with Hungary
Voices // 4 days ago
Iran uprising recalls bloody parallels with Hungary
Dec. 2 (UPI) -- Iran's nationwide uprising has dark and bloody parallels with the Hungarian uprising of 1956, when tens of thousands of students, leaderless at first, took to the streets of Budapest and were fired on by state police.

Donald Trump's impeachment: 21st century firing on Fort Sumter?
Voices // 1 week ago
Donald Trump's impeachment: 21st century firing on Fort Sumter?
Nov. 27 (UPI) -- Donald Trump can't stay president. But the impeachment inquiry is unlikely to provide sufficiently credible evidence for conviction. If Trump survives this process, do not discount his chances for re-election.

West must intervene to protect Iran's protesters, Mideast democracy
Voices // 1 week ago
West must intervene to protect Iran's protesters, Mideast democracy
Nov. 26 (UPI) -- The international community must take decisive action to limit the further loss of life in Iran. Since protests last began on Nov. 15, at least 300 activists have been killed.

Prince Andrew's 200 charities highlight value of royal patronage
Voices // 1 week ago
Prince Andrew's 200 charities highlight value of royal patronage
Nov. 25 (UPI) -- Around 3,000 organizations have charitable patronage from a member of the British royal family. That number will soon shrink by around 200 as Prince Andrew steps back from his royal duties.

City diplomacy has been on the rise; policies are finally catching up
Voices // 2 weeks ago
City diplomacy has been on the rise; policies are finally catching up
Nov. 22 (UPI) -- The gridlock in Washington can be disheartening at times, but action-oriented pragmatic mayors, who are not as constrained by party politics, can offer a glimmer of hope.

Arab Gulf states expand investment in Central Asia
Voices // 2 weeks ago
Arab Gulf states expand investment in Central Asia
Nov. 21 (UPI) -- As Gulf states diversify their investments away from the United States and Europe, ties between Central Asian countries and the Arab Middle East continue to grow.

Trending Stories

Old Man Winter's next blow to come in form of major storm
Old Man Winter's next blow to come in form of major storm
Thousands die in Japan due to overuse of antibiotics, research shows
Thousands die in Japan due to overuse of antibiotics, research shows
SpaceX launches 19th cargo mission to space station with robot aboard
SpaceX launches 19th cargo mission to space station with robot aboard
Tennessee governor says he won't intervene in Lee Hall's execution
Tennessee governor says he won't intervene in Lee Hall's execution
Indian woman on way to rape case hearing set on fire
Indian woman on way to rape case hearing set on fire

Photo Gallery

 
On the red carpet at the International Emmy Awards
On the red carpet at the International Emmy Awards

Latest News

China to exempt U.S. soybeans, pork from tariffs list
'Jersey Shore's' Mike Sorrentino celebrates four years of sobriety
'Back to the Future' creator, stars celebrate museum exhibit
U.S. smashes expectations with 266,000 jobs in November
Kacey Musgraves, James Corden sing Christmas songs, act in rom-com
 
Back to Article
/
Back to top
About UPI Contact Feedback Advertisements Submit News Tips
Copyright © 2019 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy