Land grabbing leads world's top 10 battles for environmental justice
By Julie Snorek, Autonomous University of Barcelona
In Delhi, middle-class residents and informal recyclers joined together to oppose the privatization of waste management. Photo by EPA
June 5 (UPI) -- Environmental justice activism is to this age what the workers' movement was for the industrial age -- one of the most influential social movements of its time. Yet, despite its consistent progress since the 1970s, environmental justice protests seem to get lost in the morass of information on broader environmental issues.
In contrast, labor conflicts, including strikes and lock-outs, carry such gravity that the International Labour Organization tracks these on a systematic basis. As more communities are refusing to allow the destruction and contamination of their land, water, soil and air, these, in turn, deserve to be counted.
The Environmental Justice Atlas, an inventory of social conflicts around environmental issues, fills that gap. It is funded by two successive European research projects, through a collective effort of scientists and activists. It records the failures and successes of the worldwide movement for environmental justice.
The project is directed and coordinated by Leah Temper, Daniela Del Bene and Joan Martínez-Alier at the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology at the Autonomous University of Barcelona. It has collected and categorized about 2,500 ecological distribution conflicts. These focus on who gains and who loses in development processes, arguing that these movements play a fundamental role in redefining and promoting sustainability.
In honor of World Environment Day on Tuesday, some of the highlights of the most pertinent findings, stemming from the 10 most critical categories of environmental distribution conflicts facing the world today are shown. These are listed in order of most-cataloged cases in the EJAtlas. But due to the nature of the project, this is not indicative of its global significance.
Booming palm oil production is behind a land-grabbing surge for plantations, which threatens communities. Palm oil is now in half of all packaged products sold in the supermarket. These plantations replace food crops, deprive farmers of their land, increase slave labor, cause environmental destruction like deforestation, water pollution, infertile soil and fires. Grass-roots activist networks achieved temporary suspensions of further expansion of what they call green deserts in Honduras, Colombia, México, Indonesia and Myanmar.
Alliances of grass-roots organizations are protecting the health and livelihoods of those living near waste sites by facing down a multibillion-dollar waste industry. GAIA, the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives, unites communities resisting incinerators. The Basel Action Network tries to halt the flow of hazardous waste like e-waste from being shipped from high-consumption countries to the Global South. The Global Alliance of Waste Pickers defends the informal recycling sector in more than 28 countries. In Delhi, middle-class residents and informal recyclers joined together to oppose the privatization of waste management and the resulting introduction of incineration.
Despite government restrictions, China is swept by large-scale protests against the highly flammable petrochemical Paraxylene, used to make plastic and polyester. Protests in Xiamen in 2007 stopped the construction of a plant. Protests spread to Dalian, Chengdu, Shanghai and elsewhere. Together with protests against incinerators, wastewater issues and coal-fired power plants for example, a new type of a-political mass mobilization has emerged.
Nuclear power is criticized because of risks illustrated by accidents in Three Mile Island (1979)], Chernobyl (1986) and Fukushima (2011)]. Particularly controversial were the more risky fast-breeder reactors in Creys-Malville France, where an activist died. In Kalkar, Germany and Monju, Japan there were also serious risks. These were stopped but struggles at other places, such as Kalpakkam in India are ongoing. Accidents and grass-roots movements have succeeded in slowing down the nuclear industry, leading to phase-outs in many countries.
Despite the impact of pesticides on the environment and human health where it can cause cancer and kill birds, its use in farming is increasing -- especially in developing countries. Sadly, it's usually only when the impact of these toxins have become irreversible that people demand justice for the related health challenges.
In Argentina the use of glyphosate in soybean cultivation is being disputed. In Asia, Latin America and Africa, the use of a nematicide to kill worms threatening banana plantations is being fought. These remain uphill battles.
The EJAtlas shows that people all over the world, organized in groups and networks, struggle for the kind of world they want to create, and in doing so, are promoting sustainability. Environmental conflicts are not disruptions to smooth governance, fixable with market solutions and technology. People are expressing grievances, aspirations and political demands. They should not be repressed; they should lead us to a better world for all.
The EnvJustice research project studies and contributes to the global environmental justice movement. The EnvJustice team is composed of Sofia Avila, Daniela del Bene, Federico Demaria, Irmak Ertör, Juan Liu, Joan Martinez-Alier, Sara Mingorria, Grettel Navas, Camila Rolando Mazzuca, Brototi Roy, Arnim Scheidel, Julie Snorek (Institute of Environmental Science and Technology, Autonomous University of Barcelona) and Nick Meynen (European Environmental Bureau)