Sections
Log in
Top News
U.S. News World News Featured Voices
Odd News
Entertainment
Movies Music TV
Sports
Soccer NFL NBA MLB
Photos
News Entertainment Sports Features
More...
Defense Featured Science Health Video Archive Almanac
About Feedback Privacy Policy
About Feedback Privacy Policy
Search
U.S. News
Dec. 1, 2019 / 4:18 PM

Supreme Court appears cautious in case of terminated NYC gun law

By
Daniel Uria & Don Jacobson
The Supreme Court heard arguments Monday about a former New York City gun law. File Photo by Kevin Dietsch/UPI | License Photo

Dec. 1 (UPI) -- Arguments Monday before the U.S. Supreme Court concerning a former New York City gun law indicated that justices on the high court bench might be inclined to dismiss the case as moot.

The direction of questions during oral arguments from the court's liberal justices, as well as from Chief Justice John Roberts, revealed little appetite for expanding the Second Amendment rights of gun owners, legal analysts said.

Gun advocates hoped a ruling against the superseded New York City regulation -- which barred gun owners from taking firearms outside city limits -- would set a precedent for judges weighing the public interest as part of the rulings on gun laws. Opponents feared such a decision would make it much harder to enact new gun control laws.

Instead of addressing such politically charged issues, the majority of the court's questions Monday centered on whether it's proper to consider the case since the city subsequently rescinded the regulation and the state of New York passed legislation barring its revival.

RELATED Ten injured in shooting in New Orleans' French Quarter

"You're asking us to opine on a law that's not on the books anymore," Justice Sonia Sotomayor told attorney Paul Clement, who represented three gun owners and the National Rifle Association.

Roberts, meanwhile, asked whether gun owners could still seek damages if the high court were to find the case moot.

Monday's hearing represented the first time in about a decade the Supreme Court agreed to weigh in on Second Amendment rights. The rescinded New York law barred licensed gun owners from taking their handguns to shooting competitions, gun ranges and second homes outside city limits. It was challenged by a trio of residents who argued it violated the Second Amendment rights and was not a safety issue.

RELATED Democrats give Trump deadline for impeachment participation

The law was upheld by a federal appeals court, but the city repealed it and passed a new law that ensures licensed owners can take their weapons to any location where they are permitted by law to have one.

New York State, New York City and multiple gun safety advocacy groups asked the Supreme Court to dismiss the case as moot in light of the changes, but it declined.

Chris Cox, executive director of the National Rifle Association's Institute for Legislative Action, had said the group was confident the high court would reject the city's attempt to avoid a review.

RELATED Supreme Court to hear Louisiana abortion law case March 4

The Supreme Court has declined to rule on gun rights cases since ruling in 2008 the Second Amendment protects keeping guns at home for self defense, and a 2010 clarification that said the right was valid nationwide.

  • Topics
  • Chris Cox
  • Supreme Court
  • Sonia Sotomayor
  • John Roberts

Latest Headlines

Arizona couple found dead of likely hypothermia after being buried in snow
U.S. News // 11 hours ago
Arizona couple found dead of likely hypothermia after being buried in snow
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- An elderly Arizona couple has died of likely hypothermia after being found buried in snow, authorities said Saturday.

Trump halts designating Mexican drug cartels as terrorist organizations
U.S. News // 15 hours ago
Trump halts designating Mexican drug cartels as terrorist organizations
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- President Donald Trump said he's halting plans announced late last month to designate Mexican drug cartels as terrorist organizations.

Veterans, dignitaries remember Pearl Harbor attack in Hawaii
U.S. News // 16 hours ago
Veterans, dignitaries remember Pearl Harbor attack in Hawaii
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- One of the last remaining survivors of the USS Arizona attended a ceremony Saturday marking the 78th anniversary of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, along with other veterans and dignitaries.

Judiciary committee releases report on historical arguments for impeachment
U.S. News // 16 hours ago
Judiciary committee releases report on historical arguments for impeachment
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- The House judiciary committee released a report Saturday outlining historical arguments for impeachment of the president.

New Jersey man pleads guilty in GoFundMe scam that netted $400K
U.S. News // 17 hours ago
New Jersey man pleads guilty in GoFundMe scam that netted $400K
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- A New Jersey man pleaded guilty for being the mastermind behind a crowd-funding scheme that netted more than $400,000.

Esper: Pentagon reviewing screening process after Pensacola shooting
U.S. News // 18 hours ago
Esper: Pentagon reviewing screening process after Pensacola shooting
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- Secretary of Defense Mark Esper said the Pentagon plans to review the screening process for foreign students after a deadly shooting at Naval Air Station Pensacola, Fla.

Nashville police capture 3rd of 4 teens who escaped jail
U.S. News // 18 hours ago
Nashville police capture 3rd of 4 teens who escaped jail
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- Police in Nashville captured the third of four teens suspected of committing violent crimes who escaped a juvenile detention center last weekend.

Developing weather pattern has forecasters on early alert for potentially significant storm
U.S. News // 19 hours ago
Developing weather pattern has forecasters on early alert for potentially significant storm
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- As a stormy pattern resumes in the eastern United States during the second week of December, meteorologists are pondering the path and impact of a storm around the middle of the month.

PG&E announces $13B settlement for claims related to California fires
U.S. News // 19 hours ago
PG&E announces $13B settlement for claims related to California fires
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- Pacific Gas and Electric has reached an approximately $13.5 billion settlement for claims related to multiple deadly fires in California.

Supreme Court refuses to lift block on federal executions
U.S. News // 22 hours ago
Supreme Court refuses to lift block on federal executions
Dec. 7 (UPI) -- The Supreme Court has refused the U.S. Department of Justice's request to overrule a lower court's decision to block the government's plan to resume federal executions.

Trending Stories

Arizona couple found dead of likely hypothermia after being buried in snow
Arizona couple found dead of likely hypothermia after being buried in snow
Supreme Court refuses to lift block on federal executions
Supreme Court refuses to lift block on federal executions
Judiciary committee releases report on historical arguments for impeachment
Judiciary committee releases report on historical arguments for impeachment
Nashville police capture 3rd of 4 teens who escaped jail
Nashville police capture 3rd of 4 teens who escaped jail
Veterans, dignitaries remember Pearl Harbor attack in Hawaii
Veterans, dignitaries remember Pearl Harbor attack in Hawaii

Photo Gallery

 
Moments from the Fashion Awards in London
Moments from the Fashion Awards in London

Latest News

Famous birthdays for Dec. 8: Nicki Minaj, Teri Hatcher
On This Day: Reagan, Gorbachev sign INF Treaty
UPI Almanac for Sunday, Dec. 8, 2019
Report: Oceans losing oxygen at rapid rate due to climate change, pollution
Arizona couple found dead of likely hypothermia after being buried in snow
 
Back to Article
/
Back to top
About UPI Contact Feedback Advertisements Submit News Tips
Copyright © 2019 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy