Advertisement

Experts: Ahead of NATO summit, Trump foreign policy rattles allies

By Hannah Wiley, Medill News Service
Jens Stoltenberg, secretary general of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, meets with U.S. President Donald Trump at the White House on May 17. Photo by Andrew Harrer/UPI
Jens Stoltenberg, secretary general of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, meets with U.S. President Donald Trump at the White House on May 17. Photo by Andrew Harrer/UPI | License Photo

WASHINGTON -- With the North Atlantic Treaty Organization's annual summit approaching, some experts say U.S. President Donald Trump's precedent-shattering foreign policy decisions could hamper the gathering and bolster Russia's global agenda.

"When the union strength of NATO is undermined, the first one that feels the sense of victory is President [Vladimir] Putin and Moscow," Mark Simakovsky of the Atlantic Council said in an interview. "The Russians have sought for years for ways to split up the alliance to showcase the United States as an untrustworthy ally."

Advertisement

Putin's most recent testing of NATO's resolve involves increasing military activity in Ukraine. Amid NATO infighting, Russia could benefit from a fractured alliance that he's managed to distract, Simakovsky said.

NATO, which was created to solidify transatlantic relations between North America and Europe after WWII to protect North Atlantic countries from the Soviet Union, has endured trying moments in its history, when members disagreed on important global affairs. But experts like Simakovsky, who served at the Pentagon during the Obama administration, say Trump's recent foreign policy moves are unprecedented and could tarnish the United States' international reputation as a reliable leader in global affairs.

Advertisement

Trump's decision to pull out of the multi-lateral Iran nuclear deal caused a wave of frustration among NATO members and European allies who saw the United States as a central player in keeping Iran's nuclear program from further development. German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Emmanuel Macron, leaders of two of the U.S.'s closest allies, have said they are concerned with how reimposed U.S. sanctions on Iran will affect business deals for European companies that interact with Iranian firms.

Trump's announcement Thursday to impose aluminum and steel tariffs on European allies is the most recent risk to a cohesive NATO alliance. The decision to place a 25 percent tariff on steel and 10 percent tariff on aluminum came after U.S. Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin threatened to tie an exemption from trade tariffs on NATO and European partners - which includes Germany and France -- to only those countries that meet NATO's defense spending target of 2 percent of GDP. The most recent data show that the United States, the United Kingdom and Greece are the only ones of the 29 NATO countries who met the quota in 2017.

Advertisement

Dan Hamilton of the Center for Transatlantic Relations at Johns Hopkins University in Washington, D.C., said this trade-off approach "shakes confidence and trust and viability of NATO."

"You pay me and I'll protect you; if you don't pay enough, maybe I won't protect you," Hamilton said. "That's not exactly the basis of a strong alliance. I think it rattles a lot of allies who are looking to the U.S. for protection."

This bargaining strategy could further exacerbate resistance to working with the United States on building an alternative to the Iran deal, and will leave allies hesitant to meet that 2 percent defense spending goal, Simakovsky said.

Merkel and Macron still feel burned by the United States pulling out of the Iran deal, and, as a result, might approach the NATO summit resisting Trump's demands, foreign policy experts said.

Simakovsky acknowledged NATO's nearly seven decades of resilience and argued that previous U.S. administrations have also disagreed with the NATO majority at times. But Trump's dedication to an "America First" agenda in particular has created an isolation between the United States and its allies that has been unseen previously, he said.

"There's some real questions about whether some members in the NATO alliance continue to view their interests as aligning with the United States and that inevitably will bleed into the discussions about NATO's future and NATO's strength," Simakovsky said. "If allies like France and Germany, which are critical pillars in the NATO alliance, believe that the United States is making decisions that are contrary to their interests and contrary to the interests of European security, then there will be a belief that the United States maybe isn't the critical pillar in the NATO alliance."

Advertisement

Trump met at the White House on May 17 with NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg to discuss the agenda for the summit. During a joint press briefing, Trump remained adamant that member countries must increase their spending on defense. The United States spent over 3.5 percent of its GDP on national security measures last year, far outpacing the other 28 alliance members.

The NATO summit is set for July 12 in Brussels.

Stoltenberg, who said there is "more need for the alliance now than ever," emphasized a three-year trend of all NATO countries steadily increasing their defense spending.

"That's important," Stoltenberg said. "Because we live in a more unpredictable world, and we need to invest in our security."

Stoltenberg nodded to Trump's pressure on alliance members to increase their defense outlays, saying the president helped to convince countries they need to contribute more.

Expectations for next month's summit, therefore, are limited. Close diplomatic observers warn it's not likely that European countries affected by Trump's diplomatic decisions will suddenly agree to the American administration's demands.

As Simakovsky added, "The devil is in the details."

Latest Headlines