House passes tax reform bill as Senate GOP struggles for unity

President Donald Trump visited the Capitol to rally support for the House bill.

By Doug G. Ware
House passes tax reform bill as Senate GOP struggles for unity
(L) House Ways and Means Chairman, Kevin Brady, R-Texas, is greeted by (C) House Majority Leader, Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif. and Speaker of the House Paul Ryan R-Wis., during a press conference with Republican House Leadership after the chamber passed the Tax Cuts and Jobs act on Thursday. Photo by Pete Marovich/UPI | License Photo

Nov. 16 (UPI) -- The U.S. House of Representatives on Thursday approved its version of a sweeping tax overhaul package -- clearing a key hurdle in Congress as Senate Republicans battle to find a version to advance one of President Donald Trump's chief goals.

The House passed H.R. 1 -- the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act -- by a vote of 227-205 following a rally at the Capitol led by Trump.


Thirteen Republicans voted against the bill -- 10 shy of the number needed to derail it. All Democrats opposed it.

Wednesday, several House Republicans indicated they would vote it down -- mostly moderates from high-tax states.

RELATED Senators clash over changes to tax bill

The Senate's version, which is undergoing markup this week, has been far more contentious because it contains a provision to de-penalize the federal requirement that uninsured Americans buy health insurance coverage under the Affordable Care Act.

Trump and Republicans have been trying for months to dismantle the ACA. This week, the Senate finance committee attached the issue to its tax reform package -- which would remove the financial penalty for not buying ACA coverage, a provision government analysts say would save more than $330 billion over the next 10 years. The Senate bill aims to use those savings to pay for other tax cuts.


Wednesday, Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin became the first Republican in the upper chamber to publicly oppose its present version of the bill -- saying he's concerned the corporate tax rate will fall to 20 percent, while the top pass-through rate won't see much of a drop. Sen. Susan Collins of Maine has expressed concern for including the ACA provision in the proposal.

RELATED Lawmakers, Trump voice concern for tax reform issues

Analysts project that cutting out the mandate -- which ensures sufficient ACA participation to bring down overall costs -- would result in an initial premium hike of about 10 percent.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said Wednesday that by including the mandate, the chamber's tax plan does not work for middle-class Americans.

"[The bill] raises premiums on average Americans healthcare by 10% so they can give the wealthy a tax cut. Sound familiar?" he said on Twitter. "Remember Trumpcare?"

RELATED CBO: Repealing ACA's individual mandate would save $338B

Senators on the finance committee rigorously debated the ACA mandate in the bill Wednesday night and chair Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, said markup could last into Friday.

Latest Headlines


Follow Us