The Department of Education filed a motion urging a bankruptcy court not to provide relief for a 65-year-old man with more than $220,000 in federal student loans, saying he still has plenty of opportunities to find work and pay them off. File photo by zimmytws/Shutterstock
BOSTON, Oct. 20 (UPI) -- The Obama administration moved to block a bankruptcy court from erasing federal student loan debt, saying such an allowance would jeopardize the fiscal stability of the loan program.
U.S. Department of Education attorneys, intervening in the case of a 65-year-old man seeking to erase his student loans in bankruptcy, filed a motion urging the court to stand firm with borrowers who claim they are in a dire financial situation. Attorneys argued that Robert Murphy of Massachusetts, unemployed and of retirement age, has plenty of chances to go back to work or hit the jackpot
No student debtors should get a break unless there is a "certainty of hopelessness" with circumstances that have a "total incapacity" to change, court documents said said.
"An individual's economic circumstances may change over time," attorneys said. "Improvements in the national economy may offer new employment prospects, changes in family circumstances may reduce the number of the debtor's dependents, a spouse may enter or reenter the workforce, or the debtor may benefit from an inheritance or other windfall."
Murphy requested the First Circuit Court of Appeals discharge several Parent Plus student loans, backed by the Department of Education, he took out for his children. Murphy is asking the court to define what "undue hardship" means when it comes to repaying student loan debt. A win for Murphy could change the way U.S. bankruptcy courts handle outstanding student loan debt.
Murphy lost his $165,000-a-year job as president of a manufacturing company in 2002. While looking for work in the past 13 years, he's dried up his retirement savings and his home was recently foreclosed. Murphy estimates if he were to find a $50,000-a-year job now and pay until he turns 77, the balance of his loans would still grow to $500,000 with interest.
Court records show Murphy took out twelve loans between 2001 and 2007, totaling $220,765.
The Department of Education's filing stands in sharp contrast to the Obama administration's previous support for bankruptcy protection for those with private student loans, in direct opposition to part of a 2005 law championed by Vice President Joe Biden.
Beginning in the 1970s, lawmakers began changing bankruptcy laws to edge out student loans from release. In 2005, Biden, then a U.S. senator from Delaware, helped secure legislation that would permanently bar both public and private student loans from bankruptcy protection.
In early October, the administration announced it wants to rescind the law for private education loans, saying there are fewer consumer protections than with federal loans.
"There are strong grounds for maintaining different standards for federal student loans," the Education Department said. "Federal loans are not underwritten, have generous terms and protections, and the payments can be limited based on income. Private student loans, by contrast, are underwritten and most do not have a built in income- driven repayment plan."
Education debt has become a leading talking point for candidates seeking Republican and Democratic nominations for president. If Biden decides to make a bid for the Democratic nomination, his work on bankruptcy laws and student loans could open even more debate.
Nationally, student loans are the second-largest class of U.S. consumer debt behind mortgages. Since 2006, student debt has more than doubled from less than $600 billion to more than $1.2 trillion. The average balance is about $30,000.