Advertisement

Report: States should switch to one-drug execution protocols

Constitution Project report on the death penalty finds problems with capital punishment from arrest through execution.

By
Frances Burns
Protesters chant and pray near the Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Prison in Jackson, Ga., on Sept. 21, 2011 before the execution of Troy Davis. Many of his supporters believe Davis was wrongly convicted of killing off-duty Savannah Police Officer Mark MacPhail, in 1989. UPI Photo/David Tulis
Protesters chant and pray near the Georgia Diagnostic and Classification Prison in Jackson, Ga., on Sept. 21, 2011 before the execution of Troy Davis. Many of his supporters believe Davis was wrongly convicted of killing off-duty Savannah Police Officer Mark MacPhail, in 1989. UPI Photo/David Tulis | License Photo

WASHINGTON, May 7 (UPI) -- A group of former governors, judges and other experts recommended Wednesday that the United States should switch to a one-drug protocol for executions.

The report, "Irreversible Error," by the Constitution Project, found problems with the way the penalty is carried out in the U.S. and by the legal procedures that precede executions. Prepared by people on both sides of the issue, the report took no position on the use of the death penalty.

Advertisement

Last week, Clayton Lockett, a convicted killer in Oklahoma, died of a heart attack 10 minutes after prison officials decided to halt his execution. Another man who was scheduled to be put to death immediately after Lockett was granted a two-week stay.

The report found that much in the justice system from arrest through appeals increases the possibility that innocent people will be charged with capital crimes, convicted and even executed. A majority of police departments do not routinely videotape interrogations, increasing the chance of false confessions; public defenders are often underpaid and overworked; and prosecutors sometimes conceal evidence favorable to the defense with little penalty.

Advertisement
RELATED Stays sought for two killers because of botched Oklahoma execution

The panel said the system is also biased against racial minorities, and states have too much leeway in deciding which convicts are too mentally ill or disabled to be executed.

The report found that three-drug protocols like the one used in Lockett's execution are often faulty. In some cases, the panel said, prisoners are not given enough anaesthetic as the first drug.

The experts said a large dose of anesthetic -- the method used in most cases to put down animals in the U.S. -- would be surer. But companies supplying anesthetics might not be willing to do so for executions.

RELATED Obama: Botched Oklahoma execution 'highlights' problems with application of death penalty

President Obama said after Lockett's execution that he had asked Attorney General Eric Holder to review the use of the death penalty.

RELATED U.N. condemns Oklahoma execution

RELATED Official: Guards used Taser on Clayton Lockett hours before apparently botched execution

RELATED Oklahoma governor promises 'thorough' review of apparently botched execution

RELATED Oklahoma inmate suffers fatal heart attack in botched execution

RELATED Study suggests significant number of death row inmates were wronfully convicted

Latest Headlines