Sections
Log in
Top News
U.S. News World News Featured Voices
Odd News
Entertainment
Movies Music TV
Sports
Soccer NFL NBA MLB
Photos
News Entertainment Sports Features
More...
Defense Featured Science Health Video Archive Almanac
About Feedback Privacy Policy
About Feedback Privacy Policy
Search
Trending
Dope Christmas sweater
WWE Hall of Fame
Sam Pittman
$120,000 banana
PetSmart horse
Miss Universe
New Zealand volcano
Mystery boat
Elizabeth Warren
Wild horses
Abortion
Top News
Dec. 30, 2001 / 3:11 PM

Year Ahead: The future of multiculturalism

By
STEVE SAILER, UPI National Correspondent

LOS ANGELES, Dec. 30 (UPI) -- Multiculturalism is a word of great flexibility. In social life it often means no more than a benignly favorable attitude to the ethnic and cultural heritage of other Americans -- even to such developments as "fusion" cuisines that blend Asian and European recipes.

In law and policy, however, it is a catchall term describing both attempts to ensure more equal economic outcomes between different ethnic groups, such as affirmative action preferences, and programs to preserve the cultural identity of such groups such as official bilingualism.

Paradoxically, the future of such programs is threatened by their expansion.

Multiculturalism began, in effect, as "biracialism." For generations, government had treated whites far better than blacks. From roughly 1948 to 1977, a reversal took place. Government policy paused briefly at equal treatment, or "color-blind" policies. By the early seventies, however, it was mandating an array of compensatory preferences for blacks in the name of "affirmative action."

But legislators, bureaucrats, the courts, and activists for other groups -- such as women, the disabled, other ethnic minorities and certain immigrant groups -- soon expanded the programs to cover these other presumed victims of discrimination who became known as "protected classes." Thus, compensatory preferences for the descendents of slaves quickly mutated into a generalized system of ethnic preferences, taking from some groups and giving to others.

But is multiculturalism (aka "diversity") a stable system?

Two main factors determine popular support for it.

First, programs that on average simply redistribute resources within families (such as quotas for women and the disabled) tend to generate less resentment than those that take from one set of families (such as white families) and give to another (such as Hispanic families). In the first case, we feel we are giving to ourselves; in the second to other people -- especially when government policy is emphasizing not the common nationhood of all Americans but their cultural and ethnic separateness.

For example, wheelchair ramps are highly popular, in part because they are an insurance system that may someday benefit somebody in one's own household. Similarly, job quotas for women take from men and give to their mothers, sisters, wives, and daughters. So although there is some resentment among the white males thus disadvantaged, the net effect on families as a whole is not all that great.

Second, and more important, the ratio of those who receive to those who must pay under affirmative action is critical. Blacks were a sizable minority when affirmative action preferences begin in 1969. On the other hand, with whites outnumbering blacks almost six to one, the cost to the typical white family was not large enough to persuade whites to oppose the programs strongly.

For the same reason, very few people objected (or even noticed) in the early 1970s when preferences were quietly extended to new immigrant groups such as Hispanics -- and even to illegal aliens. The price paid then by the average non-Hispanic white family still looked to be trivial because there had been so little immigration since the cutoff in 1924. The political elite did not understand that the 1965 Immigration Act was about to radically change the ethnic balance of America.

Today Hispanics outnumber African-Americans, and, owing to both immigration and relatively high birth rates, they are expected to continue growing rapidly in numbers. President Clinton publicly looked forward to whites becoming a minority by mid-century. And this rising number of non-black minority voters encourages politicians to grant them more special preferences, such as President Bush's proposed amnesty for Mexican "undocumented workers."

At the same time, as the number of members of "protected classes" -- including legally favored immigrant groups -- increases, the cost to those not enjoying preferential status, mainly white males, rises proportionately. And this is likely to stimulate opposition to such preferences. Mass immigration is thus making the future of multiculturalism radically unstable. This long-term process has ominous implications for national unity and ethnic harmony.

Whether the upsurge of national unity provoked by Sept. 11 will change matters is an open question. It has certainly altered the psychological balance between the common national identity of all Americans and their separate ethnic or sexual identities --emphasizing the former and downplaying the latter. Some feminists, for instance, have publicly worried that almost all the heroes at the World Trade Center were male and that the media failed to seek out some female role models. It might be possible in these circumstances to gain general public support for re-ordering official policies to compensate people along lines of actual individual need rather than presumed group discrimination. It would certainly be prudent in the light of immigration and America's changing demographics.

But the ethnic pressure groups and government agencies that favor the current system of preferences have not disbanded -- and they see multiculturalism not as an antidote to patriotism but as the patriotism of an America that is just around the corner.


(Steve Sailer is UPI's National Correspondent, based in Los Angeles.)

Latest Headlines

Gallup: Record number of Americans delayed serious medical treatment
U.S. News // 53 seconds ago
Gallup: Record number of Americans delayed serious medical treatment
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- A record 25 percent of U.S. adults said they or a family member delayed treatment for a serious medical condition in the past year because of cost, Gallup said Monday.

French patrol boats to guard economic zones, build 'European maritime capacity'
Defense News // 1 hour ago
French patrol boats to guard economic zones, build 'European maritime capacity'
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- French President Emmanuel Macron announced the order of six patrol vessels, each 230 feet long, to help guard the country's exclusive economic zone.

LA-area Nativity scene shows Jesus, Mary, Joseph in cages at border
U.S. News // 1 hour ago
LA-area Nativity scene shows Jesus, Mary, Joseph in cages at border
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- A Nativity scene in Southern California that depicts a baby Jesus, Mary and Joseph in separate cages at the U.S.-Mexico border has drawn attention as a statement against the Trump administration's immigration policy.

Justice Dept. watchdog finds no evidence of bias in Russia inquiry
U.S. News // 3 hours ago
Justice Dept. watchdog finds no evidence of bias in Russia inquiry
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- The Justice Department watchdog said Monday efforts by authorities to surveill a member of President Donald Trump's campaign as part of the Russia investigation were rife with mistakes, but contained nothing improper.

Caroline Kennedy christens Navy's new John F. Kennedy aircraft carrier
Defense News // 1 hour ago
Caroline Kennedy christens Navy's new John F. Kennedy aircraft carrier
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- Caroline Kennedy christened the future USS John F. Kennedy, the second next generation Ford-class aircraft carrier, Saturday at a ceremony in Newport News, Va., attended by more than 20,000 people.

Drug giant Sanofi to buy U.S. biotech firm Synthorx for $2.5B
World News // 1 hour ago
Drug giant Sanofi to buy U.S. biotech firm Synthorx for $2.5B
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- French pharmaceutical giant Sanofi SA said Monday it will buy California-based biotechnology firm Synthorx for $2.5 billion.

British judge gives 'classic psychopath' rapist 33 life sentences
World News // 2 hours ago
British judge gives 'classic psychopath' rapist 33 life sentences
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- Serial British rapist Joseph McCann was sentenced Monday to 33 life sentences for a two-week run of sex crimes and abductions earlier this year that targeted 11 victims, including a young boy.

China says Uighur Muslims have 'graduated' from camps
World News // 2 hours ago
China says Uighur Muslims have 'graduated' from camps
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- China claimed ethnic Uighurs once held in detention centers in the western region of Xinjiang have all been released, while criticizing the United States for "attacks and smears."

Supreme Court refuses to hear opioid case involving OxyContin makers
U.S. News // 2 hours ago
Supreme Court refuses to hear opioid case involving OxyContin makers
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- The Supreme Court declined to hear a case Monday that accused Purdue Pharma of moving billions of dollars in an effort to shield them from a spate of pending lawsuits over the drug OxyContin.

Supreme Court allows divisive Kentucky abortion law to begin
U.S. News // 2 hours ago
Supreme Court allows divisive Kentucky abortion law to begin
Dec. 9 (UPI) -- The Supreme Court declined Monday to hear arguments over a new Kentucky rule that requires physicians show women seeking abortions ultrasound images of their unborn fetuses, allowing the controversial law to take effect.

Trending Stories

New Zealand volcano: Officials say at least 5 dead, 'no signs of life'
New Zealand volcano: Officials say at least 5 dead, 'no signs of life'
Houston, Huntsville, Fayettesville police officers dead in line of duty
Houston, Huntsville, Fayettesville police officers dead in line of duty
House 'presumably' will present impeachment articles this week: Nadler
House 'presumably' will present impeachment articles this week: Nadler
New Jersey man pleads guilty in GoFundMe scam that netted $400K
New Jersey man pleads guilty in GoFundMe scam that netted $400K
FBI investigating shooting at Navy base as act of terrorism
FBI investigating shooting at Navy base as act of terrorism

Photo Gallery

 
Emma Watson, Saoirse Ronan attend 'Little Women' premiere in NYC
Emma Watson, Saoirse Ronan attend 'Little Women' premiere in NYC

Latest News

Gallup: Record number of Americans delayed serious medical treatment
Scientists figure out how accumulating dust particles become planets
U.S. soccer star Megan Rapinoe named Sports Illustrated's Sportsperson of Year
Dave Matthews Band to perform Feb. 28 in Las Vegas
California deputy rescues cat with head stuck in ramen noodle bag
 
Back to Article
/
Back to top
About UPI Contact Feedback Advertisements Submit News Tips
Copyright © 2019 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy