Sections
Log in
Top News
U.S. News World News Featured Voices
Odd News
Entertainment
Movies Music TV
Sports
Soccer NFL NBA MLB
Photos
News Entertainment Sports Features
More...
Defense Featured Science Health Video Archive Almanac
About Feedback Privacy Policy
About Feedback Privacy Policy
Search
Trending
Taylor Swift
Niecy Nash
Meteor shower
Cop charged
Presidents Cup
Impeachment
#MeToo Pentagon
British election
North Korea
Referee KO'd
Health News
Oct. 3, 2019 / 9:55 AM

Partial hip replacement may be better than total replacement, study suggests

By
Elizabeth Heubeck, HealthDay News
About 500,000 U.S. adults each year get a total hip replacement following a fracture. Photo courtesy of HealthDay News
About 500,000 U.S. adults each year get a total hip replacement following a fracture. Photo courtesy of HealthDay News

In recent years, the number of U.S. adults getting total hip replacements -- meaning both a new ball and joint socket -- following a hip fracture has soared to an estimated 500,000 annually.

That's nearly three times the rate at which these adults undergo a partial hip replacement, which only replaces the ball of the hip joint.

But a new Canadian study that compared the short-term outcomes of both surgeries showed somewhat surprising conclusions.

"What we now know is that within two years of having either a total or partial hip replacement, there's no difference, and possibly more harm, with total replacements," said lead author Dr. Mohit Bhandari, academic head of orthopedic surgery at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario.

RELATED Family history of diabetes linked to increased bone fracture risk

The global study randomly assigned an estimated 1,500 patients -- all of whom were 50 or older with a hip fracture but able to walk independently -- to receive either a total or partial hip replacement.

Researchers wanted to learn, first and foremost, which group would be more likely to need a secondary hip procedure within two years of follow-up. They also analyzed differences between the two groups with regard to function and quality of life, as well as the development of serious adverse effects.

Most differences proved negligible. About 8 percent of patients in both groups needed to undergo a second hip procedure within 24 months of follow-up. Patients who received a total hip replacement reported slightly better function, less pain and stiffness than those with the partial hip replacement. But the improvements weren't enough to be clinically significant.

RELATED Poor social life associated with lower bone density in older women

The difference in serious complications between the two groups perhaps came as the biggest surprise. Serious complications occurred in 42 percent of patients with a total hip replacement, compared to 37 percent among those with a partial hip replacement.

Bhandari suggested that the adverse effects suffered by either group may not have been a direct result of surgery, but added that any time you undergo a more complex surgery that takes longer, your risk of complications is likely to increase.

The findings were published recently in the New England Journal of Medicine.

RELATED Chemical in antibacterial products may weaken women's bones

A quick glance at the findings suggests that partial hip replacement is the way to go. But experts urge consumers not to jump to this conclusion.

"The study only looks at outcomes two years out," said Dr. Claudette Lajam, spokesperson for the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Many patients who opt for partial hip replacement, she said, end up returning to their surgeon later for additional surgery.

Here's one of the main reasons why. "A metal ball sitting in a native socket doesn't feel good after a while," explained Lajam, an assistant professor of orthopedic surgery at the NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital and Center for Musculoskeletal Care in New York City. After time, the natural cartilage of the individual's socket wears down as it moves against the artificial surface of the "metal ball" that is surgically implanted during a partial hip replacement.

Cost is generally not a deciding factor in which surgery to get, either. Most insurance plans, including Medicare and Medicaid, cover hip replacement surgery and associated costs. But a patient's age and anticipated remaining life span can and should play a pivotal role in the decision.

Bhandari explains: "Someone who's 51 may believe strongly they don't mind the potential of earlier risk for longer-term gain. But patients who are 90 may want to see less risk with similar earlier benefits."

While the study does provide new insights into some of the likely short-term outcome differences between partial and total hip replacements, it's unlikely to serve as a game-changer among candidates for hip surgery.

"It's a very individualized decision," Bhandari observed. "No patient with a hip fracture will fall under a blanket guideline."

More information

Visit the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons for more on hip replacement surgery.

Copyright 2019 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

Latest Headlines

Premium changes, Medicaid expansion driving ACA enrollment drop
Health News // 2 hours ago
Premium changes, Medicaid expansion driving ACA enrollment drop
Dec. 13 (UPI) -- Why have fewer Americans used the federal insurance exchange this year than in years past? Increased premiums for enrollees that receive subsidies, more states expanding Medicaid and expansion of non-ACA plans.

CDC: 1,300 Americans have died from flu so far this year
Health News // 5 hours ago
CDC: 1,300 Americans have died from flu so far this year
Dec. 13 (UPI) -- More than 4,000 new cases of influenza were confirmed across the country this week as flu season shifts into high gear.

New study shakes up thinking on hormone replacement therapy
Health News // 7 hours ago
New study shakes up thinking on hormone replacement therapy
The debate about postmenopausal hormone therapy and breast cancer risk may have turned muddier: A new study suggests that two different types of hormone therapy have opposite effects on women's long-term risk.

Liquid biopsy may predict breast cancer recurrence
Health News // 8 hours ago
Liquid biopsy may predict breast cancer recurrence
Dec. 13 (UPI) -- A new tool could make it easier to predict whether early-stage triple-negative breast cancer will return following chemotherapy, according to results of a trial using a liquid biopsy to detect circulating tumor DNA.

Breast cancer drug found effective nearly six years after treatment
Health News // 14 hours ago
Breast cancer drug found effective nearly six years after treatment
Dec. 13 -- Nearly six years after stopping a five-year regimen of the breast cancer drug anastrozole, women at high risk for breast cancer were 50 percent less likely to have been struck by the disease, new research shows.

Study: Secondhand smoke increases heart disease risk in children
Health News // 16 hours ago
Study: Secondhand smoke increases heart disease risk in children
Dec. 13 -- Secondhand smoke can harm children's arteries, a new study warns, finding that smoke caused increased stiffness in the abdominal aortas of kids in the study.

Kids whose parents are depressed have different brains
Health News // 23 hours ago
Kids whose parents are depressed have different brains
The brains of kids who have a high risk of depression because they have parents with depression are structurally different from other kids' brains, a new study finds.

Sleepy nurses could affect patient care
Health News // 1 day ago
Sleepy nurses could affect patient care
Nurses get less sleep before their scheduled shifts compared to nonwork days, which could affect patient care, according to a new study.

Partial breast radiation can stop cancer's return
Health News // 1 day ago
Partial breast radiation can stop cancer's return
A long-term study comparing two types of radiation treatment for early breast cancer found that accelerated partial breast radiation (APBI) appeared to do as well as standard whole breast radiation.

High-carb, high-sugar diets may increase risk for insomnia, study finds
Health News // 1 day ago
High-carb, high-sugar diets may increase risk for insomnia, study finds
Dec. 12 (UPI) -- Women may be able to rest easier, simply by eating more fruit, vegetables and fiber, a new study suggests.

Trending Stories

U.S. 'epidemic of loneliness' questioned by new studies
U.S. 'epidemic of loneliness' questioned by new studies
High-carb, high-sugar diets may increase risk for insomnia, study finds
High-carb, high-sugar diets may increase risk for insomnia, study finds
Kids whose parents are depressed have different brains
Kids whose parents are depressed have different brains
Sleepy nurses could affect patient care
Sleepy nurses could affect patient care
Liquid biopsy may predict breast cancer recurrence
Liquid biopsy may predict breast cancer recurrence

Photo Gallery

 
Adam Sandler, The Weeknd attend premiere of 'Uncut Gems' in LA
Adam Sandler, The Weeknd attend premiere of 'Uncut Gems' in LA

Latest News

Democrats threaten to skip LA debate over union dispute
NYC police arrest 13-year-old in stabbing death of college student
Historically unselfish LeBron James says Lakers have 'no energy takers'
Lockheed Martin awarded $18M for F-35 support for Australia, UK, Canada
2 dead in Russian aircraft carrier fire
 
Back to Article
/
Back to top
About UPI Contact Feedback Advertisements Submit News Tips
Copyright © 2019 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy