April 14 (UPI) -- Keri Russell played Shag, Marry, Kill with fellow Disney alums Thursday on Watch What Happens Live.
"I'm gonna say kill JC, because he was my friend and he'll understand," Russell answered after initially pleading the fifth.
"I'm gonna say shag Justin because he's a good dancer," she added before host Andy Cohen concluded, "And you're gonna marry Ryan Gosling."
Russell co-starred with Chasez on The Mickey Mouse Club from 1991 to 1993, and with Timberlake and Gosling in 1993. She discussed Timberlake on The Tonight Show starring Jimmy Fallon in February after the singer performed at the Oscars.
"One of my best, best girlfriends that was on The Mickey Mouse Club with me, Ilana [Miller], texted me during the opening number," the actress said. "She was like, 'Are you watching this? He's good!'"
"They were, like, 12 when we were 17, so we were like, 'You know what? He's actually good!'" she joked. "Yeah, [we still see him as young], because he was, like, a little kid [on the show]."
Russell and Rhys, who married in 2013, play Elizabeth and Philip Jennings on The Americans. The FX series premiered a fifth season in March, and will conclude with a sixth and final season in 2018.