Sections
Log in
Top News
U.S. News World News Featured Voices
Odd News
Entertainment
Movies Music TV
Sports
Soccer NFL NBA MLB
Photos
News Entertainment Sports Features
More...
Defense Featured Science Health Video Archive Almanac
About Feedback Privacy Policy
About Feedback Privacy Policy
Search
Trending
Julie Ertz
LeBron James
Meteor shower
Cop charged
Presidents Cup
Ford recall
William Barr
NYC stabbing
Winter storm
Taylor Swift
Supreme Court
UPI Archives
March 17, 1987

A federal appeals court turned aside Michael Deaver's challenge...

By
LORI SANTOS

WASHINGTON -- A federal appeals court turned aside Michael Deaver's challenge to the independent counsel law Tuesday, clearing the way for the former White House aide's indictment on perjury charges.

The U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, expressing 'no opinion on the merits' of Deaver's constitutional claims, declined to extend an order blocking independent counsel Whitney North Seymour's probe of Deaver's lobbying activities.

Deaver promptly appealed to the Supreme Court, telling Chief Justice William Rehnquist he would suffer 'irreparable injury' unless Seymour is blocked from seeking an indictment.

'Unless stayed by this court, Mr. Seymour will obtain an indictment against Mr. Deaver at the first available opportunity despite his patent lack of authority to do so,' his attorneys said.

A resolution of the 'issue of the constitutionality of the independent counsel statute ... by this court is important to assure the proper enforcement of the federal government's criminal laws in a manner consistent with the United States Constitution,' they said.

A spokewoman gave no indication on when Rehnquist may act.

Earlier, the appeals panel ruled that Deaver's 'case constitutes an impermissible pre-emptive civil challenge to a criminal proceeding,' siding with Seymour's contention the challenge was premature because Deaver had yet to be charged with criminal wrongdoing.

The appeals court panel of three judges ordered that Deaver's request for an emergency stay be denied, the five-day court order blocking Seymour from acting be immediately dissolved and returned the case to the U.S. District Court 'with directions to dismiss the complaint.'

At the same time, the panel said, 'We express no opinion on the merits of appellant's (Deaver's) constitutional arguments.'

The appeals panel turned back a move by U.S. District Judge Thomas Jackson, who last week refused to extend his court-ordered delay of Seymour's probe, but passed the constitutional question to the appeals level.

Deaver, a longtime confidant of President Reagan who was deputy White House chief of staff, has challenged the constitutionality of the 1978 law that allowed Seymour to be appointed to investigate his private lobbying activities since 1985.

Seymour, who told Jackson in open court Feb. 25 that he was prepared to seek Deaver's indictment that day on four counts of perjury, declined to comment on the ruling, and it was unclear whether grand jury proceedings would commence as previously scheduled on Wednesday morning.

In a 21-page brief filed with the appeals panel, Deaver's lawyers argued Monday that although a lower court denied his motion to stop Seymour from seeking his indictment on perjury charges, it expressly sent the constitutional question to the appeals panel.

Delaying action on the question, the lawyers said, 'would serve no legitimate interests, would irremediably harm Mr. Deaver and would cast a lengthening shadow over the legality and propriety of numerous independent counsel investigations currently under way.'

The case could affect others, notably the probe into the Iran arms-Contra aid scandal, because Deaver's challenge is the same argued by Lt. Col. Oliver North, the ex-White House aide trying to stop the criminal investigation into the affair.

Both men contend the 1978 Ethics in Government Act usurps the constitutional power of prosecution reserved for the executive branch because it provides for independent counsels to be appointed under the judiciary branch.

Lawrence Walsh, probing the Iran-Contra case, and James McKay, investigating former White House aide Lyn Nofziger's private lobbying activities, have accepted parallel Justice Department jobs from Attorney General Edwin Meese in a move to sidestep the constitutional question. Seymour and another special prosecutor, Alexia Morrison, so far have rejected the dual positions.

North, who also challenged Walsh on the dual appointment, had two lawsuits rejected last week by a federal judge on grounds his arguments were premature because he has not been charged with any wrongdoing.

Seymour also argued the appeals court's interference on constitutional grounds would be premature because Deaver had not been indicted.

'Indeed,' Seymour said, 'if this court were to hear (Deaver's) claim, it ... is no exaggeration to say that the floodgates would be opened to piecemeal appellate review.'

Latest Headlines

Google Earth now covers more than 98 percent of the populated world
World News // 14 minutes ago
Google Earth now covers more than 98 percent of the populated world
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- The Google Earth platform has now been able to cover 98 percent of the world's populated areas.

Samoan government extends state of emergency amid measles outbreak
World News // 41 minutes ago
Samoan government extends state of emergency amid measles outbreak
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- The Samoan government announced Saturday that it has extended a state of emergency meant to contain an active measles epidemic that has sickened 5,100 people and killed 72.

Joe Biden announces gun safety plan on anniversary of Sandy Hook shooting
U.S. News // 57 minutes ago
Joe Biden announces gun safety plan on anniversary of Sandy Hook shooting
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden announced his gun safety proposals Saturday, the seventh anniversary of the fatal shooting of 20 first graders and six educators at Sandy Hook Elementary in Connecticut.

Appeals court blocks Mississippi's 15-week abortion ban
U.S. News // 1 hour ago
Appeals court blocks Mississippi's 15-week abortion ban
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- A federal appeals court ruled against Mississippi's law banning abortions after the 15th week of pregnancy more than a year after the governor signed it into law.

Judge orders Wisconsin to purge over 200,000 from voter rolls
U.S. News // 1 hour ago
Judge orders Wisconsin to purge over 200,000 from voter rolls
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- A judge has ordered the state of Wisconsin to kick more than 200,000 people off voter rolls before the 2020 presidential election after a lawsuit filed last month by a conservative law firm arguing they may have moved.

Quiet pattern in the Northwest to be disrupted by atmospheric river next week
U.S. News // 2 hours ago
Quiet pattern in the Northwest to be disrupted by atmospheric river next week
Overall, a break in disruptive weather is expected during the next several days across the northwestern United States. However, this break will not last long with the stormy pattern returning soon.

New Orleans declares states of emergency after cyberattack
U.S. News // 3 hours ago
New Orleans declares states of emergency after cyberattack
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- New Orleans Mayor LaToya Cantrell has declared a state of emergency after a cyberattack on the city's computer network.

UNESCO drops anti-Semitic Belgian carnival event from cultural list
World News // 3 hours ago
UNESCO drops anti-Semitic Belgian carnival event from cultural list
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- The United Nations cultural heritage organization removed Belgium's carnival celebration from its cultural heritage list over anti-Semitic representations in the event.

California governor rejects PG&E bankruptcy plan
U.S. News // 4 hours ago
California governor rejects PG&E bankruptcy plan
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- California Gov. Gavin Newsom has rejected Pacific Gas and Electric's plan to exit bankruptcy and pay a $13.5 billion settlement to Northern California wildfire victims.

Ousted Sudanese President Bashir sentenced to 2 years
World News // 5 hours ago
Ousted Sudanese President Bashir sentenced to 2 years
Dec. 14 (UPI) -- A judge sentenced former Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir to two years in prison Saturday on charges of corruption, possessing foreign currency and accepting illegal gifts.

Trending Stories

California governor rejects PG&E bankruptcy plan
California governor rejects PG&E bankruptcy plan
Judge orders Wisconsin to purge over 200,000 from voter rolls
Judge orders Wisconsin to purge over 200,000 from voter rolls
Philadelphia Flyers' Oskar Lindblom, 23, diagnosed with rare bone cancer
Philadelphia Flyers' Oskar Lindblom, 23, diagnosed with rare bone cancer
Famous birthdays for Dec. 14: Offset, James Comey
Famous birthdays for Dec. 14: Offset, James Comey
Megyn Kelly says 'Bombshell' poster confused her son, 6
Megyn Kelly says 'Bombshell' poster confused her son, 6

Photo Gallery

 
Fidel Castro over the years
Fidel Castro over the years

Latest News

Google Earth now covers more than 98 percent of the populated world
Samoan government extends state of emergency amid measles outbreak
Joe Biden announces gun safety plan on anniversary of Sandy Hook shooting
Appeals court blocks Mississippi's 15-week abortion ban
Judge orders Wisconsin to purge over 200,000 from voter rolls
 
Back to Article
/
Back to top
About UPI Contact Feedback Advertisements Submit News Tips
Copyright © 2019 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy