Subhanna Beyah, 25, was arrested Friday as she exited a treatment facility in Queens, the New York Post reported.
New York State Police worked with Miami detectives to track her down while she was on the run from a Florida arrest warrant.
Beyah is accused of stealing nearly $500,000 worth of jewelry from Rogers' Miami Beach hotel room in March.
She was arraigned Sunday and ordered held until she is extradited to Florida.
Police said Beyah was part of a group of four women accused of drugging wealthy men they met at popular clubs in southern Florida and stealing their valuables.
The suspects, who have been identified as Beyah; Johnnina Miller, 25; Keshia Clark, 27; and Ryan Elkins, 23, have allegedly drugged and stolen items from at least 12 men, authorities said.
The Broward County Sheriff's Department has issued arrest warrants for the women on charges of one count of grand theft each.
Benedict Cumberbatch's dramatic reading of R. Kelly lyrics is just what you need
Gal Gadot cast as Wonder Woman for 'Batman vs. Superman'