facebook
twitter
rss
account
search
search
 

Animal rights activists lose case against Ringling Bros. Circus

Feb. 17, 2013 at 4:12 PM   |   Comments

SAN JOSE, Calif., Feb. 17 (UPI) -- A San Francisco area federal jury said circus workers didn't deprive animal rights activist filmmakers of free speech rights.

It took the San Jose jury just a little more than an hour on Thursday to decide plaintiffs Deniz Bolbol and Joseph Patrick Cuviello, longtime Bay area activists, didn't suffer a chilling effect on their constitutional rights when the workers sprayed the activists with fire hoses, shone laser pointers in their eyes and camera lenses and entangled them with rope, the Bay area's mercurynews.com reported.

The plaintiffs showed videos from their website, Humanity Through Education, in which Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus elephant handlers are seen beating elephants in order to manage them, mercurynews reported.

"We've been gathering this evidence for 10 years now, but Ringling manages to convince the public that they're doing things differently now -- that those practices were in the past. So we have to have current evidence that it's still going on, which is why we filed this suit. Without our freedom of speech upheld, we can't go on to the next step," Bolbol said.

The lawyer for the circus said the activists tried to film the circus employees in August 2010 by standing on a 7-foot wall and lifting cameras on monopods above the wall to film into a private areas where the animals and performers relax between shows.

© 2013 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Any reproduction, republication, redistribution and/or modification of any UPI content is expressly prohibited without UPI's prior written consent.
Most Popular
1
Bill Clinton hints he expects to be grandfather by first of October Bill Clinton hints he expects to be grandfather by first of October
2
Rutgers sophomore Caitlyn Kovacs dead after visit to Delta Kappa Epsilon frat house Rutgers sophomore Caitlyn Kovacs dead after visit to Delta Kappa Epsilon frat house
3
Man who raped pit bull puppy sentenced to five years in prison Man who raped pit bull puppy sentenced to five years in prison
4
School accused of using girl as rape bait; girl gets attacked School accused of using girl as rape bait; girl gets attacked
5
Cop-killer suspect Eric Frein possibly spotted, in standoff Cop-killer suspect Eric Frein possibly spotted, in standoff
Trending News
Video
x
Feedback