facebook
twitter
rss
account
search
search
 

Wash. court weighs in on spit burger case

Feb. 7, 2013 at 8:55 AM   |   Comments

OLYMPIA, Wash., Feb. 7 (UPI) -- A ruling by the Washington Supreme Court backs a police officer's contention he can sue for distress suffered after finding phlegm on his Burger King hamburger.

Clark County Deputy Sheriff Edward Bylsma said he drove his marked squad car through drive-through of one of the fast-food chain's restaurants in the Vancouver area in March 2009 and ordered a hamburger. He said when he removed the top bun he found a glob of spit, which DNA testing later confirmed matched the saliva of a Burger King employee.

Bylsma sued Burger King in U.S. District Court for negligence, product liability and vicarious liability, claiming the incident led him to become ill and lose sleep.

The judge dismissed the case and Bylsma appealed to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which asked Washington's highest state court to weigh in on the applicable state law.

The state high court ruled 6-3 Jan. 31 that the Washington Product Liability Act does allow people to seek damages in such cases under certain circumstances, Courthouse News Service reported.

"Common sense tells us that food consumption is a personal matter, and contaminated food is closely associated with disgust and other kinds of emotional turmoil," state Supreme Court Justice Steven Gonzalez said. "Thus, when a food manufacturer served a contaminated food product, it is well within the scope of foreseeable harm consequences that the individual will suffer emotional damages."

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer reported the state high court's opinion doesn't resolve the issue but provides the federal appellate court guidance in its handling of the matter. The supreme court's decision could allow Bylsma's case to go forward, though it made clear a plaintiff must show any emotional distress is a "reasonable reaction" to what happened and can be measured, the online newspaper said.

The Post-Intelligencer said the Burger King employee, Gary Herb, was given a 90-day jail term after pleading guilty to a related assault charge.

© 2013 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Any reproduction, republication, redistribution and/or modification of any UPI content is expressly prohibited without UPI's prior written consent.
Most Popular
1
Six Flags fight leaves boy critically injured, may have been organized on Twitter Six Flags fight leaves boy critically injured, may have been organized on Twitter
2
Body of missing Realtor Beverly Carter found Body of missing Realtor Beverly Carter found
3
One shot in Albemarle High School shooting, shooter in custody One shot in Albemarle High School shooting, shooter in custody
4
Patient admitted to hospital with potential Ebola virus Patient admitted to hospital with potential Ebola virus
5
$900,000 Porsche Spyder catches fire at gas station $900,000 Porsche Spyder catches fire at gas station
Trending News
x
Feedback