John Huttick, 48, was telling the jury Wednesday how Matthew Brunelli, 23, allegedly cost him an eye with a punch to the face Aug. 18, 2011, at the New Princeton Tavern when the crying Huttick's prosthetic eye fell out of the socket, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported Thursday.
Judge Robert Coleman granted the mistrial motion from defense attorney Eileen Hurley, calling the incident an "unfortunate, unforeseen incident."
"I couldn't believe it just came out," Huttick said after the mistrial was declared.
Coleman set a new trial date for March 4.
N.J. man wakes up from 10-hour sleep with knife in back
Police: Sword-wielding man demanded free tacos