UPI en Espanol
facebook
twitter
account
search
search

Judge won't order Nativity scene for city

Nov. 19, 2012 at 4:20 PM

SANTA MONICA, Calif., Nov. 19 (UPI) -- A federal judge indicated Monday she will not force Santa Monica, Calif., to permit a Christmas display in the city's Palisades Park.

A Nativity scene has been erected annually in the park for nearly 60 years before the city banned all displays, the Los Angeles Times reported.

U.S. District Judge Audrey Collins rejected a request for a preliminary injunction from Nativity scene proponents, but ordered all parties back in court Dec. 3 for more hearings.

Last year, requests for park display spots exceeded what the city had allocated, and officials held a lottery to distribute them, the newspaper said. Atheists won 18 of 21 spots, a Jewish group won one and the traditional Christmas Nativity story that used to occupy 14 spots was jammed into two, the Times said.

Then city officials decided a yearly lottery was too costly, and banned all private displays.

Nativity scene proponents filed suit in federal court in October to allow the traditional Christian displays, but in a tentative ruling, Collins rejected a request to erect the Christmas display while the case is pending, the Times reported.

Related UPI Stories
Top Stories
John Nash and wife, subjects of 'A Beautiful Mind' film, dead in crash
Arizona Sheriff Joe Arpaio requests new judge and public assistance with legal fees
Islamic State says it can soon buy nuclear weapon, smuggle it into U.S.
Malaysia finds mass graves with possibly 'hundreds of skeletons'
Department of Justice releases drone guidelines; protects privacy