Jack Trout, a historian and rare coin collector in Northern California, uncovered a news item from the Jan. 1, 1900 edition of the Bulletin of the American Iron and Steel Association, reporting on the theft of $30,000 in gold coins stolen from the vault of the San Francisco Mint.
The 1,427 coins found last week by the couple had a face value of $27,000 and were dated 1847 to 1894. They were in mint condition and in chronological order, indicating they might have been unused.
Trout's theory is strengthened by the inclusion of one particular coin, an 1866 Liberty $20 gold piece that did not include the words "In God We Trust."
“This was someone’s private coin, created by the mint manager or someone with access to the inner workings of the Old Granite Lady (San Francisco Mint),” Trout said. “It was likely created in revenge for the assassination of Lincoln the previous year (April 14, 1865). I don’t believe that coin ever left The Mint until the robbery. For it to show up as part of the treasure find links it directly to that inside job at the turn of the century at the San Francisco Mint.”
Rare coin dealer Don Kagin said the couple plans to sell the coins, some of which may fetch more than $1 million each at auction, but first they are "loaning some to the American Numismatic Association for its National Money Show, which opens Thursday in Atlanta."
[San Francisco Chronicle]