Holder rejected D.C. vote bill findings

Published: April 1, 2009 at 7:53 AM
President Obama speaks at installation ceremony for Attorney Gen. Holder in Washington

WASHINGTON, April 1 (UPI) -- U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder rejected a finding that allowing a seat in Congress for the District of Columbia was unconstitutional, sources say.

The finding, delivered by the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, found that a bill pending in Congress to give the district a vote in the House of Representatives for the first time was unconstitutional but Holder overrode those findings, sources briefed on the issue told Wednesday's Washington Post.

"The attorney general weighed the advice of different people inside the department, as well as the opinions of legal scholars, and made his own determination that the D.C. voting rights bill is constitutional," Holder spokesman Matthew Miller told the Post, adding that the attorney general didn't base his decision on politics.

After the OLC lawyers delivered their assessment, Holder reportedly sought the opinion of the solicitor general's office, where lawyers told him that they could defend the legislation if it were challenged after its enactment.

Backers of the D.C. measure contend that its constitutionality has been endorsed by such legal voices as the American Bar Association and former federal appellate judge Kenneth Starr, the Post said.

© 2009 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Order reprints



Additional News Stories
Federer assures No. 1 status with ATP win (22 min)
Real Alice's 'Looking Glass' to be sold (35 min)
Report: N.D. quarterback got in bar fight (48 min)
Deer stunned by Toronto police (54 min)
Grain futures mixed Tuesday
Poll: Women ignoring new mammogram advice
Toyota Tundra pickup trucks recalled
fark
Having already unlocked the achievement for weirdest nation in the world, Japan goes for the bonus...
Train Man
Not news: Babysitter goes drunk driving. News: He had a seven year with him. FARK: The kid was on...
Celebrated trial lawyer died driving unsafe and uncrashworthy SUV on negligently designed and maintained...
Even the judge agrees there's nothing wrong with a little tongue
That Kentucky census worker undressed himself, wrote "fed" on his chest, bound himself in duct tape...