Doctor defends asbestos diagnoses

Published: Nov. 18, 2008 at 2:48 PM
Order reprints
DETROIT, Nov. 18 (UPI) -- A Lansing, Mich., doctor says he used the best information available to him when he diagnosed thousands of patients with asbestos-related illnesses.

Dr. R. Michael Kelly of Mid-Michigan Physicians, testifying Monday in a Detroit courtroom, defended himself against accusations he was paid millions of dollars from attorneys representing his patients, who are suing their former employers in asbestos cases, the Detroit Free Press reported.

Under questioning from attorneys representing about 70 defendants, Kelly maintained that asbestos illness is variable and hard to diagnose, saying, "Shortness of breath is subjective. It's like asking what color brown are these walls. Rarely do we have all the data. You have to arrive at decisions with the info you have and proceed with that decision."

Lawyers for the employers have filed a motion with Wayne County Circuit Judge Robert Colombo Jr. to exclude about 80 diagnoses made by Kelly, contending that radiologists have disputed nearly all his X-ray diagnoses, the Free Press reported. The employers also allege Kelly may have misused a machine called a spirometer to measure lung capacity.

If Kelly's testimony is barred, it could leave the former employees scrambling to find another expert to confirm their diagnoses, the newspaper said.


© 2008 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.



Bratton: Tox tests key in Jacko death (3 min)
IMF downgrades Ukraine 2009 GDP (9 min)
Doctors: Canada abdicating isotope role (12 min)
Deep tremors may foretell quake (18 min)
Sprint transfers management to Ericsson (19 min)
EU seizing more counterfeit goods (30 min)
Mubarak:Gilad Shalit to be set free soon (37 min)
fark
Afghanistan revises 'marital rape' law, no longer requires women to submit to sex with their husbands;...
Angry that you're being paid in California IOUs? Blame fat people
New billboard in Florida aims to stop people from talking on their cell phones while driving, do...
And lo, Nestlé said unto the FDA "let my cookie-dough flow"
The City of Denver would like you to know that they are not issuing more parking tickets just because...
Next up on the Wheel of Media Fearmongering: Ship smokestacks and how they'll kill us all