Right to show pictures of fetuses upheld

Published: July 3, 2008 at 5:15 PM
Order reprints
LOS ANGELES, July 3 (UPI) -- A federal appeals court has ruled that anti-abortion activists had a First Amendment right to display pictures of aborted fetuses outside a California school.

A three-judge panel on the Ninth Circuit reversed a district judge's ruling Wednesday, the Los Angeles Times reported.

The court said that there is no "heckler's veto" on free speech, that the right can not be limited by the reaction of the audience.

The Center for Bio-Ethical Reform filed suit against the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department after the 2003 incident at a middle school in Rancho Palos Verdes. Assistant Principal Art Roberts called the department because a truck with pictures of fetuses on three sides was circling the school. Roberts testified at the lower court hearing that he had to stop boys from throwing stones at the truck and that the pictures upset many students.

Deputies searched the truck, questioned the activists for more than an hour and then ordered them to leave the area of the school.

"It's the off-putting speech that needs protection, otherwise there is no need for the First Amendment," said Robert Muise, a lawyer for the center.


© 2008 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.



Jockstrip: The world as we know it. (2 min)
Your Daily Horoscope
The almanac
Panetta: Congress not told of CIA program
Biden goes on the road to defend stimulus
The two-edged sword of online games
Rio Tinto employees face spy charges
fark
Over a 30-day period, U.S. Marshalls arrested over 35k figitives netting 2,356 sex-offenders, 433...
Tennessee Aquarium presents a bowl full of ugly-ass baby penguin. A little milk and we'll have a...
Judge allows Twitter-using DA to 'tweet' upcoming muder trial over defense objections. Prosecution's...
Photoshop theme: The end of the universe
NY Times thinks their website users would pay five bucks per month. Listen, for the last time, no...
Fewer calories allow monkeys to live longer. Good thing you're not a monkey