Precedent overlooked in child-rape ruling

Published: July 2, 2008 at 7:53 AM

WASHINGTON, July 2 (UPI) -- U.S. Supreme Court justices overlooked the new military justice code when they declared there were few precedents for executing child rapists, observers say.

The high court ruled last week that implementing the death penalty for those convicted of raping a child was unconstitutional, partly because the federal law had no provisions for it, nor did the vast majority of U.S. states that allow capital punishment. Nowhere in the evidence considered by the court, however, was there a mention that such a provision is included in revisions to the Uniform Code of Military Justice, The New York Times reported Wednesday.

The fact was disclosed over the weekend on a military blog written by Dwight Sullivan, a civilian defense lawyer handling death penalty appeals. Sullivan told the Times he was reading the Supreme Court's decision on a plane and was surprised to see no mention of the military statute.

Lawyers for the accused child rapist said they weren't aware of the military provision and the Justice Department had no comment. R. Ted Cruz, who argued the case in support of the death penalty, told the Times the chances the court would reconsider the decision were "extremely unlikely," even if the omission was pointed out.

© 2008 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Order reprints



Additional News Stories
NBA: Cleveland 104, Portland 99 (8 min)
NHL: Edmonton 5, St. Louis 3 (9 min)
NBA: Chicago 96, Golden State 91 (OT) (12 min)
NHL: Buffalo 2, Chicago 1 (15 min)
NBA: New York 113, New Orleans 96 (35 min)
UPI NewsTrack Sports (37 min)
UPI Sports Calendar for Saturday, Dec. 12
fark
I have no idea what you're talking about, so here's a picture of a man stroking frenzied tiger sharks...
You can't get an H1N1 shot because ... (shakes magic 8 ball) ... it's too cold to ship it anywhere...
First ever Peeps store opens. "They manage to straddle the world between cute and horrible. You...
The annual "Here, look at this crazy, old woman who threw up Christmas all over her house" video...
It took the highest court in Nebraska to determine walking from the parking lot to your workplace...
Finally, a new place to stick my sausage