Court ruling renews Gitmo closing argument

Published: June 13, 2008 at 7:02 AM
Order reprints
Defense Secretary Robert Gates in Washington on May 20, 2008. (UPI Photo/Alexis C. Glenn)
Defense Secretary Robert Gates in Washington on May 20, 2008. (UPI Photo/Alexis C. Glenn) | Enlarge Enlarge
WASHINGTON, June 13 (UPI) -- The U.S. Supreme Court's ruling allowing Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, prisoners access to civilian courts reopens debate for closing the facility, observers said.

U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates is among administration officials who said it should be shuttered, the opposite view of U.S. President George Bush, who said the center should remain open and is considering introducing legislation to blunt the ruling's effect, the Los Angeles Times reported Friday.

The 5-4 Supreme Court decision Thursday allowing prisoners to appeal their detentions in civilian courts undercuts the administration's main reason for opening the facility: keeping detainees out of the U.S. civilian court system.

Civilian detention proceedings differs from those at Guantanamo, said Charles D. Stimson, who also has overseen detainee affairs at the Pentagon. For one, detainees will have lawyers who can present evidence and question witnesses.

Some lawyers said defending against the petitions would burden the government, pressuring the administration to send detainees to their home countries, The New York Times reported.

The ruling could affect about 130 detainee incarcerated because the administration doesn't intend to charge them with war crimes but said they're too dangerous to release, the Times said.


© 2008 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.



Al-qaida allies behead seven Somalis (1 min)
MLB: Boston 1, Kansas City 0 (4 min)
MLB: Cincinnati 3, New York Mets 0 (17 min)
MLB: Philadelphia 3, Pittsburgh 2 (20 min)
Couple with large adoptive family killed (28 min)
Gays plan vigil for slain sailor (30 min)
UPI NewsTrack TopNews (32 min)
fark
Photoshop these creepy earrings
Patronizing Tijuana hookers while on drugs may be unhealthy, according to Dr. N.S. Sherlock, of...
Defense lawyers request words like "polygamy,""cult" and "compound" not be used in their client's...
TSG Mugshot roundup: Twin billing
Barbie-Con visitors split on major issue: Are you allowed to open her box and play with it?
It's been 10 years since "The Blair Witch Project." Where were you when this crappy, one-joke, overhyped...