Calif. hears same-sex marriage challenge

Published: March. 4, 2008 at 3:53 PM

SAN FRANCISCO, March 4 (UPI) -- Opponents of California's same-sex marriage ban told the state Supreme Court Tuesday that the ban was in the same vein as a 1940s ban on interracial marriage.

In oral arguments in San Francisco, the plaintiffs argued that the state constitution protects the right of same-sex couples to formally marry based on the court's 1948 decision striking down a ban on marriage between people of different races.

The San Francisco Chronicle said the plaintiffs said the decision clearly stated that the "right to join in marriage with the person of one's choice" had been recognized by the court.

The state maintained, however, that banning same-sex marriage actually strengthens state laws on domestic partnerships.

California Deputy Attorney General Christopher Krueger also told the justices that interracial couples didn't have such partnerships to fall back on in the 1940s. He added that the law was implemented purely for racial-superiority purposes and that domestic partnerships couldn't be considered "exclusionary" since they contained all of the legal rights inherent in marriage.

The justices have 90 days to issue a ruling in the case.

© 2008 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Order reprints



Additional News Stories
Rituximab used for Graves' eye disease (7 min)
Recall of Pet Carousel products expanded (7 min)
N.J. commuter train skips stop (13 min)
Thieves sought jewelry, got shampoo (20 min)
Salvation Army sets giant kettle record (24 min)
Antarctic glacial ice loss unprecedented (27 min)
Genes predict advanced melanoma outcome (31 min)
fark
Evidence found of plot to kill cartoonist, but details are sketchy
♫The best part of waking up is a CTA bus crashing into the side of your house♫
The president calls him..."The Crustmaster"
Hello, insurance company, yeah a grizzly bear ate my airplane
Man charged with sexually assaulting 14-year-old girl over several months, even though he paid her...
If you're a cop it's probably best not to wait three days to send a runaway home. You might just...