Fla. judge orders books back in schools

Published: July 25, 2006 at 9:14 AM

MIAMI, July 25 (UPI) -- A U.S. federal judge in Florida has ordered Miami-Dade schools to return 24 children's books banned by the school board to library shelves.

U.S. District Judge Alan Gold ruled Monday that "Vamos a Cuba" and 23 other controversial books about Cuba must be returned to school libraries by next Monday, The Miami Herald reported Tuesday.

Gold said the school board "abused its discretion in a manner that violated the transcendent imperatives of the First Amendment."

The school board ordered the books removed after a parent, a former Cuban political prisoner, complained they portrayed Cuba inaccurately, the newspaper reported. The school board claimed the books were removed due to those inaccuracies, but Gold said in his ruling: "I conclude that the School Board's claim on 'inaccuracies' is a guise and pretext for 'political orthodoxy.'"

The director of the American Civil Liberties Union, which filed the suit to have the books returned to shelves, urged the school board to offer books with opposing viewpoints, instead of suppressing the current ones, the Herald said.

© 2006 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Order reprints



Additional News Stories
Mounties charge pro sports doctor (36 min)
U.S. markets up in advance of Fed decision (38 min)
OK given for 700 rooftop solar projects (56 min)
Crude oil prices top $71 per barrel
Students confirm 1920s dinosaur find
No. 1 Spain is soccer Team of the Year
Some ham sausages recalled in Canada
fark
Real men of genius. Today we celebrate you, Mr "Why the hell shouldn't I mount a rocket launcher...
German quartet sensibly and efficiently chased into freezing shipping container by marauding wild...
Wal-Mart loves supporting the troops, except when it comes to overcharging them for shipping
Photoshop this man meeting the media
Subby can't decide if this is genius or simply idiotic, even for the New Yorker
Canadian healthcare still better than U.S., except for that little glitch where old people have...