Mobile UPI  |   About UPI  |   UPI en Español  |   UPI Arabic  |   UPIU  |   My Account
Search:
Go

Court weighs reporters' phone record case

|
|
 
  
Published: Feb. 14, 2006 at 12:04 PM

NEW YORK, Feb. 14 (UPI) -- A New York federal appeals panel has heard argument about the privacy of telephone records of two New York Times reporters.

U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald wants the phone records of retired reporter Judith Miller and of Philip Shenon to learn who told them about planned December 2001 searches of Islamic charities in Chicago and Texas.

New York federal Judge Robert Sweet ruled against the government's request in February 2005, saying the 1972 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Branzburg vs. Hayes gave reporters broad First Amendment protections.

His ruling is at odds with a Washington federal appeals panel, which ruled in February 2005 that Branzburg vs. Hayes did not apply in another case involving Miller, which was about who identified an undercover CIA operative.

Monday's questioning by the New York appeals panel was largely sympathetic to the reporters' positions, The New York Times reported.

"There is no distinction between subpoenaing me and subpoenaing my phone records," Miller said outside the hearing. A decision will be made at a later date.

Topics: Judith Miller, Patrick Fitzgerald
© 2006 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Any reproduction, republication, redistribution and/or modification of any UPI content is expressly prohibited without UPI's prior written consent.

Order reprints
  
Join the conversation
Most Popular Collections
Father's Day: Celebrity dads The 2012 Miss USA competition Faces of the 2012 French Open
2012 MTV Movie Awards Queen Elizabeth's Diamond Jubilee Notable deaths of 2012
Additional Top News Stories
1 of 21
Singer Janelle Monae arrives at the 2012 MTV Movie Awards in Universal City, California
View Caption
Singer Janelle Monae arrives for the MTV Movie Awards at the Gibson Amphitheatre in Universal City, California. UPI/Jim Ruymen
fark
It's one thing to be raised by wolves. It's not the same if you're raised by goats
Do you know a con artist personally? Difficulty: no ex husbands, ex wives or girlfriends or boyfriends...
Americans would never have to deal with the current bedbug epidemic if we would only legalize DDT...
A guy on my fb just got picked up for a homicide. Do I unfriend him and look like a tool if it turns...
Daughter: hey, look what my pet bird can dance to. Parents: he's going to hell
"Slave master" husband, who severly beat wife over DS/SM marriage pact, quits as local charity director....