Mobile UPI  |   About UPI  |   UPI en Español  |   UPI Arabic  |   UPIU  |   My Account
Search:
Go

High court justices debate foreign rulings

|
|
 
  
Published: Jan. 14, 2005 at 7:33 AM

WASHINGTON, Jan. 14 (UPI) -- Two U.S. Supreme Court justices debated whether foreign court rulings should influence their decisions, USA Today reported Friday.

Antonin Scalia, appointed by President Reagan, and Stephen Breyer, appointed by President Clinton, debated the issue Thursday at Washington's American University.

"We don't have the same moral and legal framework as the rest of the world, and we never have," said Scalia, who opposes looking to foreign rulings to decide U.S. cases.

To which Breyer responded: "You can learn something" from foreign countries, adding that it is a matter of "opening your eyes to things that are going on elsewhere."

Foreign court rulings recently emerged as material to the high court's rulings. In 2003, when the majority struck down state anti-sodomy laws, it mentioned the European Court of Human Rights has affirmed a right of adults to engage in homosexual activity.

Topics: Antonin Scalia, High Court, Stephen Breyer
© 2005 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Any reproduction, republication, redistribution and/or modification of any UPI content is expressly prohibited without UPI's prior written consent.

Order reprints
  
Join the conversation
Most Popular Collections
Notable deaths of 2012 Scripps National Spelling Bee AmfAR Cinema Against AIDS gala
Indianapolis 500 Presidential Medal of Freedom Memorial Day around the nation
Additional Top News Stories
1 of 27
Snigdha Nandipati of San Diego wins Finals of the Scripps National Spelling Bee
View Caption
Snigdha Nandipati of San Diego, California watches confetti rain down as she wins the two-day Scripps National Spelling Bee championship, May 31, 2012, in National Harbor, Maryland. Nandipati successfully spelled the word .* guetapens *, meaning to lure or ambush. UPI/Mike Theiler
fark
You're an enterprising bank robber: You have 30 minutes to knock off 3 banks. GO
Veteran found buried in Florida National Cemetery without casket -- only a cardboard box. Florida...
At the unveiling of the official portrait of President George W. Bush, Joe Biden turned to Karl...
Women who know about their husband/boyfriends' porn usage less happy than women who do not know...
Smoking hot gun-toting college student: "It's my hobby to blow stuff up." Bonus: Her last name is...
You know how I know you're gay? Maybe it was your facial width-to-height ratio? The science of 'Gaydar'...