About UPI  |  UPI en Español   |   My Account
Free News Update:
United Press International - News. Analysis. Insight.™ - 100 Years of Journalistic Excellence
  • Home
  • Top News
  • Entertainment
  • Odd News
  • Sports
    • Baseball
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Olympics 2008
    • Tennis
  • Business
  • Science
  • Health
  • Analysis
    • Energy Resources
    • Security Industry
    • Emerging Threats
  • Media
    • Video
    • News Photos
  • Features
    • The Voice of Young Voters
    • Path to the Presidency
    • Energy
    • Beijing Olympics 2008
Search:
Go
You are here:  Home / Top News / Outside View: Nigh time for tax reform

Top News

View archive | RSS Feed

Outside View: Nigh time for tax reform

By LESLIE CARBONE, A UPI Outside view commentary
Published: Jan. 7, 2003 at 4:04 PM
Order reprints  |  Print Story  |  Email to a Friend  |  Post a Comment
FAIRFAX, Va., Jan. 5 (UPI) -- With so much attention focused on what President George W. Bush proposed in the way of economic reform in his Tuesday speech to The Economic Club of Chicago, the administration has a rare and promising opportunity to help America's struggling families today and for generations to come.

A 2-year window of political opportunity exists to promote fundamental tax reform that will substantially reduce taxes on working families and dramatically simplify America's Byzantine tax system.

With the prospects for significant tax reform -- and his own political clout -- buoyed by the November 2002 election, the president is expected to spend the next couple of years rallying support for the cause of dramatically altering America's progressive income tax.

That's good news for working families who pay a high price for America's behemoth tax code.

The progressive income tax applies higher marginal tax rates to people earning more. It is a selective law that levies an additional penalty on people who do well-- and it backfires badly.

Middle-class Americans were originally exempt from the income tax. First introduced as a tax on just "the rich" -- the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans -- the average two-earner family today pays more than $6,000 just in federal income taxes.

Once the tax was put in place, under the guise of "soaking the rich," it was very easy to broaden it. Now nearly everybody pays.

The government's demand for revenue during World War II provided the rationale for expansion from a class-based tax to a mass tax. Once it had begun milking the middle class, the government was loath to stop.

That's only the beginning. Progressive taxes actually make it harder for middle-class workers to find jobs in the first place. Progressive taxes discourage productivity and inhibit economic growth -- which translates into fewer available jobs for workers.

Fewer available jobs mean lower wages for those who find and keep work. Wages are highest when many employers have to compete for few workers; they are lowest when many workers have to compete for few jobs. In this setting, lower- and middle-class families suffer the most.

Though the highest marginal rates are imposed upon the most productive Americans in terms of the income they generate the real costs -- fewer jobs, lower wages, slower growth -- hit working families the hardest.

America's progressive tax policy is also morally destructive.

Progressive taxation casts suspicion on the virtuous behavior that creates wealth and is a kind of fine on prosperity. Government seizes a greater share of the fruits of the labor of hard-working, honest citizens who have prospered against the odds then their neighbors who may have not. In so doing, it stigmatizes prosperity and the virtues that produce it.

Prosperity brings less tangible benefits, such as greater freedom from worry, the trust and confidence of others, and self-respect. Virtues become habits when practiced regularly, building healthy families, healthy communities and healthy nations.

A nation that treats the fruits of virtuous behavior as sinister is a nation in moral peril because it lures its citizens toward the practice of vice rather than virtue. The resulting social-down-spiral creates greater dependency on government by infantilizing the citizenry, teaching people that they can't make it on their own without a government handicap.

With a new Congress heading into session and new economic leadership taking office shortly, the president now has a golden opportunity to reshape America's tax policy and undo the damage that the mistakes of the past century have wrought.

In the coming State of the Union address, Bush should ask the Congress and the country what kind of America tax policy should support. Should it forge a nation that honors the virtues that create wealth to everyone's benefit or one that punishes creative and responsible economic behavior and ends up hurting those who can least afford it? By adopting the right vision, the Bush economic team can remodel America's tax code into one that will strengthen -- not undermine -- the nation's moral and economic fiber.


Leslie Carbone, former director of family tax policy at Family Research Council, is the author of Slaying Leviathan: The Moral Case for Tax Reform (forthcoming).


"Outside View" commentaries are written for UPI by outside writers who specialize in a variety of important global issues.

RATE THIS ARTICLE
    Poor    1    2    3    4    5  Excellent    
Feedback


© 2003 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Have an opinion? Leave a comment. No Registration Required.
News Photos Slideshows
Photos of the Day
Week in Photos
News
Entertainment
Sports
Features
Archives
Olympics 2008
Path to the Presidency
Additional News Stories
Top News
  • FOX News poll: Obama leads McCain
  • Pirates threaten to blast ship
  • Powell says Stevens reputation 'sterling'
  • Protester disrupts Iowa McCain rally
  • Biden: Obama offers women more than McCain
Business News
  • FCC moves to reserve free wireless waves
  • UPI NewsTrack Business
  • Survey: U.S. gas prices approaching $3
  • Amtrak sets ridership record, revenue up
  • S. Korea to privatize, restructure firms
Entertainment News
  • Pitt joins Tarantino in Germany for film
  • Poll: Hurley 'safety pin' dress best gown
  • Fleet Week parade canceled in San Fran
  • Garber: Garner 'beautiful' while pregnant
  • YouTube will begin offering TV series
Health News
  • Plastic surgery makes advances in wartime
  • Lack of vitamin D can affect 36 organs
  • Abnormalities in brain of cocaine addicts
  • Negative ads can cause a physical reaction
  • Wildfires can boost ozone pollution
UPI Features - The Voice of Young Voters
Most Popular
Stories
Photos
Videos
People
1.
Iran recasts report on U.S. jet
2.
Melamine found in Cadbury products
3.
Ukraine leader dissolves parliament
4.
40 hurt when Qantas plane forced to land
5.
Leaders rule out Euro bank rescue pool




Videos
Enlarge Video
Reaction: Does peace have a prize?
Reaction: Does peace have a prize?
Friday, October 10
From Wall Street to a Maryland Main Street
From Wall Street to a Maryland Main Street
Friday, October 10
Debate #2: The economy
Debate #2: The economy
Friday, October 10
Economics vs. foreign policy in the media
Economics vs. foreign policy in the media
Thursday, October 9
© 2008 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Official Government Wires  |   About UPI  |   Site Map  |   Terms of Use  |   Privacy Policy  |   Advertise Online  |   Contact Us

Sponsored Links: Auto Dealers - College Football Tickets - Fundraisers - Press Release Services - prom dresses - Prom dresses and gowns - Public Records - Wedding and Honeymoon Experts - Motivational Sports Speakers Bureau