Lynch finished off a spectacular personal performance in dramatic game that saw Kent State rally with a 21-point fourth quarter. The No. 19 Golden Flashes brought about overtime when Spencer Keith threw a 19-yard touchdown pass to Tim Erjavec with 44 seconds to go in regulation.
Both sides managed a field goal in the first overtime, but Lynch put 18th-ranked Northern Illinois in front to start the second extra period.
Kent State moved the ball to the Northern Illinois 9-yard line, but faced fourth down and the game ended when Demetrius Stone intercepted a throw by Keith.
Northern Illinois built a 31-17 lead through three quarters on the running and throwing of Lynch, who completed 19-of-34 passes for 212 yards and picked up 160 more yards on 36 carries. He accounted for four touchdowns, three of them on the ground. Lynch ran 9 yards for a score with 3:12 to play in the fourth quarter, putting Northern Illinois in front 37-30.
Akeem Daniels added 128 rushing yards and a touchdown for the Huskies, who won for the 12th time in 13 games. Their only loss this season was a one-point setback to Iowa in their opening game of the campaign.
Kent State (11-2) was led by 190 passing yards from Keith, who threw two interceptions.
Ray Liotta sues skin care company over use of likeness
Aaron Carter is still in love with Hilary Duff