Nic Moore added 14 points as the Mustangs (19-5, 8-3 AAC) recorded their first such win since 1987 and remained unbeaten at home (13-0) with an eighth win in nine games overall.
Fans rushed the court after the victory -- the Mustangs' third triumph over a ranked opponent this season. They are likely to break into the Top-25 when new rankings are released Monday.
SMU hasn't made the NCAA Tournament since 1993.
The Bearcats (22-3, 11-1) had their 15-game winning streak snapped due in part to 17 turnovers.
Sean Kilpatrick led Cincinnati with 22 points.
McPhee, Cokas 'working on their marriage' after affair
Duggar sisters unveil Christian dating rules in new book