The Lightning nearly ended the game seconds earlier when Alex Killorn pulled Jets goalie Al Montoya out of the net but clanged a shot off the post.
Winnipeg then advanced into the Bolts' zone and Wheeler found Scheifele alone at the right side of the net for the game-winner.
Wheeler also scored in regulation for Winnipeg, which completed a six-game road trip with a 4-2-0 mark.
Montoya stopped 28-of-29 shots.
Nate Thompson scored and Anders Lindback made 34 saves for Tampa Bay.
Teacher apologizes for showing sexual image of herself in class
Scarlett Johansson steps out with fiance after pregnancy reveal