Peyton Peyton passed for 307 yards, hooking up with Wes Welker and Julius Thomas on scoring strikes for the Broncos (2-0).
The elder Manning -- coming off a seven-touchdown performance last week against Baltimore -- had prevailed over Eli twice previously, both times when he was playing for the Indianapolis Colts.
Knowshon Moreno rushed for two touchdowns and Trindon Holliday returned a punt 81 yards for a score for Denver.
Eli Manning went 28-of-49 through the air for 362 yards and a touchdown but was intercepted four times for the Giants (0-2), who dropped a second straight to begin the season for the first time since 2007.
Victor Cruz led New York's receiving corps with eight catches for 118 yards.
Millions of Getty images now available for free via embed tool
Ray Liotta sues skin care company over use of likeness