New York is 1-1 on its eight-game road trip while the Dodgers had a four-game winning streak snapped.
Belisario (4-6) issued a leadoff walk in the ninth, who was immediately erased on a fielder's choice grounder off the bat of Robinson Cano.
Cano moved to second on a ground out by Alfonso Soriano, after which Ichiro Suzuki was intentionally walked. Overbay followed with a single to center that brought home Cano and the Dodgers then suffered a miscue that allowed the Yankees to add two runs.
Both Suzuki and Overbay scored when a grounder by Jayson Nix was botched for an error by second baseman A.J. Ellis.
NBC reportedly holds celebs hostage to Jimmy Fallon's show
Boston schools pull out free condoms over wrapping complaints