Lehman won the yearlong points competition on the tour each of the last two seasons, but has yet to post a victory in 2013.
The large group at 70 included major championship winners Corey Pavin, Jeff Sluman, Mark Calcavecchia and Hale Irwin, who on Monday will celebrate his 68th birthday. Irwin holds the Champions Tour record for career victories with 45, the last of them coming six years ago.
This is the 13th year the tournament has been held, but it is being hosted for the first time by the almost century-old Wakonda Club.
Because of bad weather early in the week, many of the players were unable to play a practice round on the course before teeing off Friday. The hilly layout turned out to be a difficult challenge with just 25 players breaking par.
There were 20 scores of 76 or higher with Fuzzy Zoeller turning in an 84.
Moore to attend retreat in to avoid Kutcher's wedding
'How to Train Your Dragon 2' releases 5-minute clip