The Jets won their second in a row and kept the Panthers stuck on seven victories this season, fewest in the NHL.
Byfuglien, without a goal in his last 13 games, broke past two defenders in the slot and sent a wrist shot past the glove of Jacob Markstrom.
Winnipeg let a two-goal lead get away before coming through in the extra period.
Andrew Ladd and Blake Wheeler scored in the opening period for the Jets, but Jonathan Huberdeau tipped in a shot with 13 seconds left in the first stanza to bring the Panthers within one. It was Huberdeau's 12th of the year.
Shawn Matthias tied it 5:50 into the third period.
The win went to Ondrej Pavelec, who made 38 saves. Markstrom allowed the three goals on 28 shots.
Ray Liotta sues skin care company over use of likeness
Aaron Carter is still in love with Hilary Duff