The Americans faltered in the first game of the final round of qualifying in the North America-Central America region. Six nations will play a 10-game, round-robin tournament throughout 2013 with the top three finishers earning a spot for next year's World Cup in Brazil.
The fourth-place finisher will then meet the winner of the Oceania division in a two-game playoff to determine the final World Cup berth.
Costa Rica, Panama, Mexico and Jamaica make up the remainder of the final group of would-be qualifiers. The United States will host Costa Rica March 22 and then faces the always difficult trip to Mexico four days later.
Chipotle plans first price increase in 3 years
Putin thinks Obama would save him if he were drowning