Cristina Fierro, now 19 and married, was 16 when she was offered to Taylor by her pimp for $300 in 2010 at a Rockland County, N.Y., Holiday Inn occurred.
Taylor, a 260-pound former linebacker who had a Football Hall of Fame career with the New York Giants, has said he thought she was 19. He has pleaded guilty to two misdemeanors, sexual misconduct and patronizing a prostitute, and received six years probation and his name on the national sex-offenders' registry.
In court Tuesday, the 110-pound Fierro, who is suing Taylor for an unspecified sum, explained the encounter, saying, "He was lying on top of me. I said I can't breathe. I was pushing him away from me."
She said she insisted Taylor wear a condom, the New York Post reported Wednesday.
"He didn't care. It was really painful," she said in court.
On cross-examination, Arthur Aidala, Taylor's lawyer, confronted Fierro with the results of the rape examination she underwent in a hospital after the incident, indicating she had been with a second man, although it was unclear who that man was, the newspaper said.