Masterson (9-10) allowed six hits and three walks but benefited from three double plays turned by the Indians' infield. The right-hander struck out four.
Chris Perez racked up his 32nd save as the Tribe took the opener of a three-game series.
Lillibridge's solo shot in the fourth inning handed Cleveland a 3-0 lead. The Indians infielder also scored three times. Jason Donald added an RBI.
The loss was hung on C.J. Wilson (9-9), who surrendered three runs (two earned) on six hits in an 6 2/3-inning outing.
Albert Pujols socked a two-run homer for Los Angeles, which fell for the ninth time in 12 games.
Video of Victoria’s Secret models trying to 'twerk' hits Instagram
Costly malfunction causes beer flood at Boston-area brewery