The Islanders took a 3-0 lead midway through the second on a goal by Michael Graber, but Colorado rallied to end a four-game losing streak. The Islanders have dropped two in a row and their 11-point total is the lowest in the Eastern Conference.
Quincey scored the game-winner with 2:39 having gone by in overtime when he took advantage of a screen provided by David Jones. The goal came on the power play after New York goaltender Al Montoya was called for a high stick.
Paul Stastny began Colorado's comeback on a power-play goal with 21 seconds left in the middle period. Milan Hejduk brought the Avalanche within one 6:07 into the third and Jan Hejda tied it with a slap shot 4:28 later.
Jean-Sebastien Giguere made 30 saves to get the win, shutting down the Islanders for the final 32 minutes. Montoya allowed four goals on 51 shots.
Video of Victoria’s Secret models trying to 'twerk' hits Instagram
Wisconsin business offering 'therapeutic cuddling' forced to close