Jonas Gustavsson stopped 29 shots for Toronto, and Lee Stempniak and Tomas Kaberle scored goals for the Maple Leafs.
Bryan McCabe, a former Maple Leaf, scored both goals for the Panthers, who have lost four of their last five.
Tomas Vokoun made 28 saves for Florida.
Rare Chinese turtles hatch at New York City zoo [VIDEO]
Salvation Army bell ringer assaulted for saying 'Happy Holidays'