The win was Yi's first on the LPGA Tour.
Yi carded an even-par 71 in the final round of regulation play and Pressel shot a 67, tying at 18-under 266.
The playoff began at No. 18, where Pressel missed a 25-foot birdie attempt before Yi won it with her birdie.
Michelle Wie (64), Seon-Hwa Lee (67) and Song-Hee Kim (69) tied for third place at 16-under 268.
The 21-year-old Yi, who lives in Murrieta, Calif., is a native of South Korea. She had not finished in the top 10 in any prior event this season.
Pistorius testifies he didn't consciously pull trigger when he shot girlfriend
Pot vending machine to debut